Which Rookie?????/

[mdub]

Who would be best to pick both pretty decent players, Magner mature age rookie, AFL ready body gunned it in VFL last year and played well in Melbourne's first games last week. Neale gun in the making for freo! Who should i go?

[elephants]

Magner if he get an upgrade and is named round 1. I have both though ;D

[Capper]

Magner if he get an upgrade and is named round 1. I have both though ;D

Magner needs to be elevated but probably will, Neale already a Senior.

Its hard to choose as i have them both. Pro Neale if he gets a start

[Chelskiman]

I don't have either, but they are on my list of rookies to keep an eye on.  If I had to choose one right now I'd be leaning towards Neale.

[fertalong]

Neale will likely get more game time and it's a widely known that Lyon rates him. I'd say if you had to pick one, go with Neale. I've got both atm.

[Windigo]

Magnar has some very impressive stats. 30 a game and is cheaper.

Lock him in if he gets elevated and performs well in the remainder of NAB.

[Justin Bieber]

Wingard or Neale? I pick Wingard... I would have him if I am not risking the ddp players from the get go

[mdub]

Wingard or Neale? I pick Wingard... I would have him if I am not risking the ddp players from the get go

Wingard is a lock for my whatley hes a boss!!! haha

[Windigo]

Please tell my that is Redden as your profile picture.

[Justin Bieber]

Please tell my that is Redden as your profile picture.

That didn't make sense, but cause we're from Brisbane and his brother is on the board for the Lions so he goes the Lions and cause he thought Redden is a better photo to have than Johnathon Brown lol.

[Jukes]

Magner or Gibson though? Neale is a lock.

[Mr.Craig]

Magner or Gibson though? Neale is a lock.

Gibson probably. They should both get game time this weekend so it'll hopefully become a bit clearer.

[Grannyboy]

Please tell my that is Redden as your profile picture. (He meant to type 'me')

That didn't make sense, but cause we're from Brisbane and his brother is on the board for the Lions so he goes the Lions and cause he thought Redden is a better photo to have than Johnathon Brown lol.

Er, that didn't make any sense either ??? You mean: That didn't make any sense(. It's) because we're from Brisbane and his brother is on the board for the Lions(, therefore) he goes (for) the Lions(.) He thought Redden (would be) a better photo to have (rather) than Jonathon Brown lol.
Some of your posts are like trying to do a cryptic crossword.

[Grannyboy]

Neale is the only senior of the three atm (Magner, Gibson, Neale). That might be saying something about him over the other two.

[mezzoculo]

The only reason not to choose Magnar and Gibson over Neale is because they are not senior listed.

Although Neale is listed as a MID he plays as a small forward - perhaps playing Balla's role when he drifts into the mids.

Gibson and Magnar, on the other hand, are mature midfield speciailists and are PROVEN ball gatherers.