Heath Scotland

[essendon2]

Tough choice,

it's the last decision I have to make before I will be very very happy with my team!

at the moment my DEF is:
_____, B.Goddard, H.Shaw, B.Deledio, R.Hargrave, M.Clarke, ______ (S.Darley, S.Morris)

and my MID is:
S.Pendlebury, M.Boyd, G.Ablett, ______, C.Wingard, L.Neale (A.Sexton, J.Magner)

[Colliwobblers]

i went option 2 for cookie cutter safety :)

[Chelskiman]

I like option 1 better.  Scotland is a star and Bower, if he plays, can score well.  Sloane is also going to be a gun this year.

[elephants]

I think...

Option 1 - for the risk and uniqueness as well as 3 potential keepers.

Option 2 - for the safety. 2 definite guns and 1 very solid looking rookie.

[Capper]

G.Birchall + T.Bugg + J.Selwood for me

[Windigo]

3 out of you have Scotland. But he is the best DT back going around!

[Justin Bieber]

Bugg will probably outscore Bower lol.

[essendon2]

Why are so many of you picking Option 2??

List your predicted averages for all 6
Birchall = ?
Scotland = ?
Bower = ?
Bugg = ?
Selwood = ?
Sloane = ?

[Windigo]

Don't read much into predictions.

[Justin Bieber]

yeah like what Windigo said, I want to keep it to myself.

[Capper]

Why are so many of you picking Option 2??

List your predicted averages for all 6
Birchall = ?
Scotland = ?
Bower = ?
Bugg = ?
Selwood = ?
Sloane = ?

G.Birchall over H.Scotland just
P.Bower over T.Bugg just
J.Selwood over R.Sloane by alot

[essendon2]

Why are so many of you picking Option 2??

List your predicted averages for all 6
Birchall = ?
Scotland = ?
Bower = ?
Bugg = ?
Selwood = ?
Sloane = ?

G.Birchall over H.Scotland just
P.Bower over T.Bugg just
J.Selwood over R.Sloane by alot

Birchall won't beat Scotland.... 95 vs 100
Bower 70 vs Bugg 60-65
Selwood 117 vs Sloane 105

[Jukes]

Those predicted averages are a bit off imo...Birch will get about 90, Scotland 95, Bower and Bugg 65 each, Sloane 90 and Selwood 115 imo.

What about Heppell, Bugg and Boyd/Ablett/Swan/Rocky?

[upthemaidens]

so you want to be stuck with sloane in your midfield for the whole year?  really   why?

[essendon2]

Those predicted averages are a bit off imo...Birch will get about 90, Scotland 95, Bower and Bugg 65 each, Sloane 90 and Selwood 115 imo.

What about Heppell, Bugg and Boyd/Ablett/Swan/Rocky?

Birchall will increase this year mate.... Sloane averaged 98 in his last 4... he won't just 90.
Already got Pendles, Ablett, Boyd