3 Big Questions

[woodenspooner]

Hey guys would love your thoughts on the following players, and aslo who you think would be a better selection

C.Newman vs B.Deledio

R.Nahas vs N.Riewoldt

L.Hayes vs T.Scully

Look forward to reading your comments

[ando_10]

deledio (he should be right to play nab game this week)

n.roo (he will go back to premium status' )

hayes (just a proven scorer)

[Capper]

Lids over Newman just as Newman is an SC gun

This is Nahas year to perform and with the Tigers on the climb could be a unique

With Hayes and Scully all i can say is watch this space. Lake and Brown have just gone down and hopefully this doesnt catch on and players injured last year going down this year

[bowyanger]

Lids and Newman an even draw at this time of year, Lids has had an injury (its not a big injury but this time of year Newman would be hitting full noise whilst Lids has been going easy = adv. Newman) , Lids more likely to get tagged

Nahas is young and doesnt have NRoo injury concerns. NRoo is a big unit and getting long in the tooth....of course attrition is going to be a massive factor on his knees, which we are starting to witness.
Nahas has it all in front of him (Young fellah)
NRoo has a fair few consistant point stealers in NDS, BJ, Montags etc

See above for Scully v Hayes.
Scully has less consistant point stealers.
Did Skull really have knee issues, or was it an excuse as Bails knew he was leaving last year?