If you had to drop one...

[elephants]

Which premium midfielder would you drop in favour of a rookie?

Swan, Pendles, Ablett, Murphy, Sloane, rookie (rookie, rookie)

Need another rookie in the middle imo. Who should be dropped for this rookie?

Thanks.

[Chelskiman]

Is there a reason why you can't drop Sloane?  I think he's set for a big year but I also think Swan, Gazza, Murph and Pendles will still average higher than him.

[Holz]

I would keep Swan, pendles and Ablett and drop murphy just be cause i dont think he is that great a pick. Not a huge fan of sloane personally, but could pay off.

[Mr.Craig]

Swan because he might drop in price in the early rounds or Murphy because he's not as much as a proven performer compared to Pendles and Ablett.

[Holz]

Swan because he might drop in price in the early rounds or Murphy because he's not as much as a proven performer compared to Pendles and Ablett.

if Swan averages the same as he did when he wasnt injured he could go up in price and he isnt that much more than pendles, who i actually think will drop in price.

[4INAROW]

+1 swan is slighlty underpriced due to injury affected games last year, he shouldn't drop for the first couple, pendles is a gun but he's sure to drop a bit early i reckon

[Capper]

if you had swan and pendles i would drop one of them, but murphy out of the 4

[Justin Bieber]

Everyone wants Murphy to go, but personally Pendles and that's what I've done. Ele your a big Murphy fan like me so keep him  8)

[mezzoculo]

Why not Sloane?
Surely Jelwood can be considered an underpriced midfielder this year due to his injury affected27 in Round 1. Why not swap Pendles for him and keep Murph?

[csboy]

Murph

[Chelskiman]

No love for Murph here.  I have him in my team as my 4th mid at the moment so I'm quite happy with that.

[elephants]

Yep loving the lack of Murph love ;D

I was meant to add Sloane into the poll! Think I'll go with droopping Sloane until I see more of his nab. ON the radar though!!

Swan, Pendles, Ablett, Murphy, rookie, rookie (rookie, rookie)

[Chelskiman]

Swan, Pendles, Ablett, Murphy, rookie, rookie (rookie, rookie)

Similar to me except I have Boyd instead of Pendles.

[Colliwobblers]

Which premium midfielder would you drop in favour of a rookie?

Swan, Pendles, Ablett, Murphy, Sloane, rookie (rookie, rookie)

Need another rookie in the middle imo. Who should be dropped for this rookie?

Thanks.

So Sloane will be your 4th. I vote Murph, SC god but DT the others will outscore him. Swan and GAJ are untouchable captains and Pendles will play the season of his career in 2012.

[PowerBug]

Pendlebury. Not sure why though. :-\