Horlin-Smith vs. Walsh???

Started by Jay, February 29, 2012, 07:05:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

What fwd rookie with a rnd 12 bye?

george h-smith
4 (57.1%)
tommy walsh
3 (42.9%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Jay

Tommy was locked in but his nab was pretty poor while horlin-smith was good!

Thoughts? :)

tor01doc

Toss a coin while you wait for further instructions.

meow meow

Neither!

Everyone will be jumping on the Medhurst clone when they see him.

Capper

going to go with Neither as well, there are other options out there

4INAROW

u probably answered your own question.

his nab form was poor, obviously watch him again over the next 2 weeks, but don't pick a rookie on hype, pick them on form and job security and u should be right.