Swanny vs. Pendles

Started by oconnell, February 29, 2012, 06:36:04 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who should i pick???

D Swan
S Pendlebury

oconnell

pretty self explanitary really, just vote in the poll!!! :)

4INAROW

swanny is underpriced due to injury affected games last year

oconnell

Still can't pick between them, keep the votes coming :)

Capper

Swan for me, will get pendles later.

Swan usually starts the year better

burner11

I have both plus GAJ in my mids the rest rookies

fever


demon_spud

Swan underpriced by 40k?

Not sure about that, plus will be out 3 weeks in last half of season, so you will have to cover that for sure.

mt_williams22

Out of those two i'd pick swan based on the price difference and the fact that the total points difference between them will be minimal.
If you are willing to take a little risk and fear not having a collingwood midfielder in your team, I would suggest Dale thomas eho in my opinion is set for a big year and good value at his price, with the idea of Pendles as an upgrade target!!

Cheers

Colliwobblers

i started swan / ablett / boyd / selwood - rooks

Having said that i did so based on price of pendles alone. He will 100% outscore swan again this season in SC and have a bigger year in general, lifted to leadership group, out of contract at end of year, he will either get a pay rise from the pies or a lotto win from the giants so he will be playing at 120%.

My point - if you can afford pendleberries - start him :)

Justin Bieber

Swan DT - Pendles SC. Upgrade target is Pendles.

fever

Quote from: Colliwobblers on March 01, 2012, 06:41:25 PM
He will 100% outscore swan again this season in SC

that's just ridiculous speculation. swan was whipping him til he got injured last year, what's to say that swan isn't better for SC or that pendles wont get a niggle? pendles might outscore him but it's no lock, so where there's doubt save the cash, simple.

Justin Bieber

Quote from: fever on March 02, 2012, 12:04:54 PM
Quote from: Colliwobblers on March 01, 2012, 06:41:25 PM
He will 100% outscore swan again this season in SC

that's just ridiculous speculation. swan was whipping him til he got injured last year, what's to say that swan isn't better for SC or that pendles wont get a niggle? pendles might outscore him but it's no lock, so where there's doubt save the cash, simple.

In SC pendles averted 129 whereas swan only averaged 121. That's why.

Ziplock

Swan also had an injury cloud for a month.

RiOtChEsS

Quote from: demon_spud on March 01, 2012, 06:26:41 PM
Swan underpriced by 40k?

Not sure about that, plus will be out 3 weeks in last half of season, so you will have to cover that for sure.

???

demon_spud

Quote from: Marcz on March 02, 2012, 12:42:00 PM
Quote from: demon_spud on March 01, 2012, 06:26:41 PM
Swan underpriced by 40k?

Not sure about that, plus will be out 3 weeks in last half of season, so you will have to cover that for sure.

???

Price difference between Swan and Pendles if your trying to compare the 2.

Swan already said that he wants to go to Arizona to recoup for the run home.  Expecting it around the bye week,  +1 week for it actually being beneficial and another for climatising and jet lag on travelling.