Ask Ziplock Pre-season NAB1

[Ziplock]

Robert Murphy as a unique?

not a fan, has only avgd near premium level once, nearly a half decade ago

pass.

[fattony]

what do ya reckon about leigh adams?

[Ziplock]

what do ya reckon about leigh adams?

he's a possibility, and would be a sneaky unique, but at the same time at that price he's *almost* premium, and you're fielding him over your martins, sidebottoms etc, that, while being more generic, are looking like better picks. I don't feel like he has the ceiling for a premo fwd.

[Master Q]

Couch. Will he play?

[Ziplock]

2nd elevation for melbourne.

[n00bsauce]

horlin-smith?

been looking at Geelongs small forwards and it looks like he might get the opportunity-

Stevie J
Chapman (runs through the midfield)
Stokes (plays midfield sometimes aswell)
Varcoe (Injuried) thanks whatlez
Christensen (midfield)
Menzel (Injured)
Byrnes (form hasn't been great)
Motlop (does he get select?)

[Doyle]

Don't know if this has been covered or not, but will you be having Magner even though a) he's injured and b) he's rookie listed

[Justin Bieber]

horlin-smith?

been looking at Geelongs small forwards and it looks like he might get the opportunity-

Stevie J
Chapman (runs through the midfield)
Stokes (plays midfield sometimes aswell)
Varcoe (Injured*)
Christensen (midfield)
Menzel (Injured)
Byrnes (form hasn't been great)
Motlop (does he get select?)

[Jackina]

Your opinion on Sandilands? Is he as good as he was since the accursed Turf Toe...?

[elephants]

Is Cox worth his 530k price tag over someone like Jacobs for 430k?

[Ziplock]

horlin-smith?

been looking at Geelongs small forwards and it looks like he might get the opportunity-

Stevie J
Chapman (runs through the midfield)
Stokes (plays midfield sometimes aswell)
Varcoe (Injuried) thanks whatlez
Christensen (midfield)
Menzel (Injured)
Byrnes (form hasn't been great)
Motlop (does he get select?)

I'm sick atm so my brain isn't working that well. But honestly, I don't know on this one. I would think there are better options out there though.

[Ziplock]

Your opinion on Sandilands? Is he as good as he was since the accursed Turf Toe...?

I think he'll be as good as always, but injuries are always a concern with him. Other options mean that I would personally overlook him, esp. since he picked up a pre-season injury.

[Ziplock]

Don't know if this has been covered or not, but will you be having Magner even though a) he's injured and b) he's rookie listed

all comes down to if he's promoted. His isn't a very long injury, so if melbourne have him promoted before round one, then he'll probably be playing early, even if not named round 1. Then, jump on :P

[Ziplock]

Is Cox worth his 530k price tag over someone like Jacobs for 430k?

Personally, I don't think so :P

I can still see cox's average slipping 5 points, and I think jacobs, with natural progression and an easy draw, will increase his average substantially.

I'm not a fan of top tier premos :P

[owenbond007]

Starting T.campbell as 4th ruck regardless of whether his elevated with cox redden giles combo?