Ask Ziplock Pre-season NAB1

[elephants]

Connors won't average 90+ or 80+ for that matter Zip. Even if he is in your Euro's team ;)

[Jukes]

Lads, Rocky and Treloar (injury?!?!?!) or Selwood and Smith?

Treloar/Smith will be fringe first team FORWARDS for me fighting with other rookies.

[Ziplock]

Selwood and Smith. Smith has been talked up in every bloody place by GWS, and selwoods scoring potential is more of a known quantity than rockys.

[reesbr]

Zip what do you think about Dan Nicholson this year? I rate him and could really breakout. Thoughts?

[Ziplock]

Zip what do you think about Dan Nicholson this year? I rate him and could really breakout. Thoughts?

well he averaged nearly 60 taking out sub affected matches. And put up some relatively impressive numbers as one (28 points in a quarter, 40/50 points in a half), so like he's under priced and has potential. He *should* be upgraded as well.

at the same time, he hasn't really shown that much scoring potential a 90 against freo, but apart from that not many scores over 60. Quite consistent though.

I can't see him being a worthwhile pick however... I just don't see it happening this season.

[reesbr]

Cheers zip. Matthew Bate?

[Mr.Craig]

Who do you think will be upgraded on to the Bombers list? They appear to have a few good options.

[elephants]

Thoughts on how many GWS rookies we should ideally have come round 1?

Currently have 6 in my team now (Darley, Bugg, Shiel, Giles, Cameron, D. Smith)

Only just traded...

McDonald OUT Hogan IN
Hampton OUT Cameron IN
Walsh OUT D. Smith IN

I think this is okay...? Thoughts?

[Justin Bieber]

Thoughts on how many GWS rookies we should ideally have come round 1?

Currently have 6 in my team now (Darley, Bugg, Shiel, Giles, Cameron, D. Smith)

Only just traded...

McDonald OUT Hogan IN
Hampton OUT Cameron IN
Walsh OUT D. Smith IN

I think this is okay...? Thoughts?

Same as me, but bugg.

[PowerBug]

Cheers zip. Matthew Bate?

I'll do this one. Kepe an eye on his positions during pre-season, see where and how long he plays for. atm he's in my side as the only fwd mid-pricer, and pretty he'll stay there barring injury.

[Ziplock]

Who do you think will be upgraded on to the Bombers list? They appear to have a few good options.

how many spots do they have again? 3? or two? I know gumbleton and prismall are on the LTI list, and fletcher is a vet....

honestly, I'm not sure. Dell'Olio I think is in for a shot, since essendons forwards aren't crash hot, but they may save the others until someone shines in vfl.

[Ziplock]

Cheers zip. Matthew Bate?

I'll do this one. Kepe an eye on his positions during pre-season, see where and how long he plays for. atm he's in my side as the only fwd mid-pricer, and pretty he'll stay there barring injury.

pretty much, he's a high draft pick who has shown he can average solid before (80 odd), coming underpriced, with a decent pre-season, and at 25 should be primed as a break out.

[Ziplock]

Thoughts on how many GWS rookies we should ideally have come round 1?

Currently have 6 in my team now (Darley, Bugg, Shiel, Giles, Cameron, D. Smith)

Only just traded...

McDonald OUT Hogan IN
Hampton OUT Cameron IN
Walsh OUT D. Smith IN

I think this is okay...? Thoughts?

wait until we find out mcdonalds TOG before you drop him imo. Apart from that, seems a LITTLE trigger happy, but solid enough. TBH you can have as many as you want, by GWS' bye you should have traded out most of your rooks anyway.

[Jukes]

I've just done a few trades Zip want your opinion on which side is better;

a) Jacobs, Neale/Couch, forward rookie

b) McIntosh, Coniglio, Byrnes.

[Ziplock]

I'm going a) it looks pretty clear to me.