Ask Ziplock Pre-season NAB1

[Capper]

lol this threads hasn't been very popular... I've done like half the Q's

atleast it helped your quota Whatlez

Hey Zip what do you think about Chappy and Stevie J, currently dont have ether as i have Goodes, Buddy and Pav. Would you select Chappy or Stevie J infront of Goodes, Buddy or Pav

well I pretty much answered this in my above post to colliwobs, but basically, I think chappy is seriously underpriced and stevie J overpriced. I don't think I would pick SJ over any of those, but would probably pick Chappy over goodes.

Cheers zipper,

[Ziplock]

my trial score is 1026 should i be worried yet?

no, doesn't mean squat :)

[Ziplock]

I would take Lids over Shaw but I managed to get both... Down to personal preference imo. Drop Birch for Shaw whatlez? Birch is a little more unstable imo as he hasn't been an elite backline premium for very long. I'd like to see how teams account for the Hawks possesion game plan. A man on man system may cut them down...

But I love Birchall lol. He's a personal favourite same Marc Murphy.

Oh yeah Zip What about this. Thoughts on Jeremy Cameron and Curley Hampton? And if what rd 11 bye players should I replace with? (Don't say Zorko)

Don't quite get the second part of the question. They're both reasonable, and will play a fair amount of games this season, but I don't see either of them having huge scoring potential. I feel kerridge and maybe even skinner could end up being better picks.

[Justin Bieber]

I'm on like 1127 :D

[Jukes]

Zip should I get Birchall, Shaw or get Lake/Howard and then use the cash to upgrade Zorko to Brynes?

[Spite]

stevie J, fyfe, gray and deledio or
chapaman, dusty, sidey and scotland or
pav, dusty, robinson, scotland or
chapman, pav, dusty, deledio... expected player averages too (for those players) would be a great help, thanks :)

PS I have shaw and goddard, and buddy and goodes in already. This is pretty much the rest of the premiums haha

[Ziplock]

Selwood + Wilkes + Darley + Boyd + Couch + 13k

OR

Swan + Heppell + Bower + Shiel + Saad + 70k

I know it's big but I am clueless right now.... ::)

I'm going the selwood + boyd combo.

[Ziplock]

Zip should I get Birchall, Shaw or get Lake/Howard and then use the cash to upgrade Zorko to Brynes?

no, go shaw and a rookie like zorko.

[Ziplock]

stevie J, fyfe, gray and deledio or
chapaman, dusty, sidey and scotland or
pav, dusty, robinson, scotland or
chapman, pav, dusty, deledio... expected player averages too (for those players) would be a great help, thanks :)

PS I have shaw and goddard, and buddy and goodes in already. This is pretty much the rest of the premiums haha

1. no. Not a fan of fyfe, stevie J or gray this year. Fyfe to average 95, stevie J 100 and gray, it all depends if he has his season ending injury in the first quarter of round one or the fourth (actually that's a little harsh, but I dislike fyfe and stevieJ eitherway). Lids for  a close to 100 average
2. Possible. Chapman 105, dusty 98, sidebottom 95 and scotland 98.
3. liking this one as well, pav for 100, dustin 98, robinson 95 as well, scotland 98.
4. this one's my favourite. Chappy 105, pav 100, dusty 98 and deledio pushing 100.

[elephants]

Thanks Zip. I should say that doing option 1 (Selwood + Boyd) Gives me a 5 premium midfield...

[Capper]

I'm on like 1127 :D

1787 for me, hopefully my smokies get up.

Zip,
What are the changes that Saad and Wilkes for the aints will play R1??

[Spite]

stevie J, fyfe, gray and deledio or
chapaman, dusty, sidey and scotland or
pav, dusty, robinson, scotland or
chapman, pav, dusty, deledio... expected player averages too (for those players) would be a great help, thanks :)

PS I have shaw and goddard, and buddy and goodes in already. This is pretty much the rest of the premiums haha

1. no. Not a fan of fyfe, stevie J or gray this year. Fyfe to average 95, stevie J 100 and gray, it all depends if he has his season ending injury in the first quarter of round one or the fourth (actually that's a little harsh, but I dislike fyfe and stevieJ eitherway). Lids for  a close to 100 average
2. Possible. Chapman 105, dusty 98, sidebottom 95 and scotland 98.
3. liking this one as well, pav for 100, dustin 98, robinson 95 as well, scotland 98.
4. this one's my favourite. Chappy 105, pav 100, dusty 98 and deledio pushing 100.

Thanks zip, those averages look close to mine, but I would think Pav would be more of a ~96 average, I just see his move forward more risky because if freo are getting killed, well, he won't get near it, so I don't think he would be so consistent.

2) 396 total
3) 387 total with pav at 96
4) 399 with pav at 96

So I'm going for option 2 :P Reasoning is that deledio has a tough draw at first and I would rather upgrade to him and starting with a very high priced scotland is a great POD until everyone else gets him in :)

Thanks again zip!

[Justin Bieber]

I'm on like 1127 :D

1787 for me, hopefully my smokies get up.

Zip,
What are the changes that Saad and Wilkes for the aints will play R1??

Wow how are you scoring so high?

[Justin Bieber]

Zip I got plenty of mids to choose from.

I need to pick 4 from a list of 6.

Which 4?

Selwood
Swan
Pendlebury
Ablett
Murphy
Boyd

[Capper]

I'm on like 1127 :D

1787 for me, hopefully my smokies get up.

Zip,
What are the changes that Saad and Wilkes for the aints will play R1??

Wow how are you scoring so high?

cause my team is just that good mate, i could tell you who i have but a normal coach cant tell an experienced coach like you whatlez what to do... ;D