Ask Ziplock Pre-season NAB1

Started by Ziplock, February 28, 2012, 11:26:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Bieber

#180
Quote from: Ziplock on March 02, 2012, 03:26:19 PM
byrnes- plenty of mid options, not so many elsewhere.

Ok thanks.

Ok I got a tough one. I need a mid bench who has the rd 13 bye. Max 104k.

Ziplock

no you don't all your cash cows should be traded out by round 13 :P

Ziplock

which is good, because there are no viable options.

Justin Bieber

Yeah I figured it out and yeah he needs to be traded lol..

What about Shaw or Lids. Shaw's bye helps out a lot.

Ziplock

*sharp intake of breath* difficult one. Ordinarily I would say lids any day of the week, but with his hammy strain he'll be a bit underdone and has a killer starting draw. Shaw'll be a touch unique, so I think I'm leaning on him...

Justin Bieber

I just made the swap, I think Shaw will start better and Lids can come in at rd 14 or so.

elephants

I would take Lids over Shaw but I managed to get both... Down to personal preference imo. Drop Birch for Shaw whatlez? Birch is a little more unstable imo as he hasn't been an elite backline premium for very long. I'd like to see how teams account for the Hawks possesion game plan. A man on man system may cut them down...

nathan11

my trial score is 1026 should i be worried yet?

Justin Bieber

Quote from: elephants on March 02, 2012, 03:48:17 PM
I would take Lids over Shaw but I managed to get both... Down to personal preference imo. Drop Birch for Shaw whatlez? Birch is a little more unstable imo as he hasn't been an elite backline premium for very long. I'd like to see how teams account for the Hawks possesion game plan. A man on man system may cut them down...

But I love Birchall lol. He's a personal favourite same Marc Murphy.

Oh yeah Zip What about this. Thoughts on Jeremy Cameron and Curley Hampton? And if what rd 11 bye players should I replace with? (Don't say Zorko)

Jukes

Quote from: nathan11 on March 02, 2012, 03:48:55 PM
my trial score is 1026 should i be worried yet?

Don't care about my teams NAB cup score tbh just what each player is scoring and how they are playing.

elephants

Selwood + Wilkes + Darley + Boyd + Couch + 13k

OR

Swan + Heppell + Bower + Shiel + Saad + 70k

I know it's big but I am clueless right now.... ::)

Jukes

Quote from: elephants on March 02, 2012, 04:29:56 PM
Selwood + Wilkes + Darley + Boyd + Couch + 13k

OR

Swan + Heppell + Bower + Shiel + Saad + 70k

I know it's big but I am clueless right now.... ::)

I'd go for the top selection, although I'd say there's a few better defender rookies then Beau Wilkes to select.

And maybe Selwood out for STANTON

Justin Bieber

Quote from: Jukes on March 02, 2012, 04:38:03 PM
Quote from: elephants on March 02, 2012, 04:29:56 PM
Selwood + Wilkes + Darley + Boyd + Couch + 13k

OR

Swan + Heppell + Bower + Shiel + Saad + 70k

I know it's big but I am clueless right now.... ::)

I'd go for the top selection, although I'd say there's a few better defender rookies then Beau Wilkes to select.

And maybe Selwood out for STANTON

Why do you want people to get Stanton? Why don't you keep it quiet and if he guns it, you will be the only person with him.

elephants

Thanks Jukes. I reckon Wilkes has easy got a spot in the best 21 of the Saints either as a key forward or back. He may only pull 50's and 60's but could be a 22 game a season bench keeper...?


Jukes

Quote from: elephants on March 02, 2012, 04:40:30 PM
Thanks Jukes. I reckon Wilkes has easy got a spot in the best 21 of the Saints either as a key forward or back. He may only pull 50's and 60's but could be a 22 game a season bench keeper...?

Yeah he will play a lot but, from his NAB cup performances, looks like another Glass/Presti style player.