Ask Ziplock Pre-season NAB1

[The F.A.R.K.]

"zip, do you wanna catch up? maybe saturday night hindley street? xx"

sorry i know it is two questions but could you please answer both

[Adamant]

What are your thoughts on Mitch Robinson?
and which 3 out of....
Pav, Robinson, NRoo, Goodes, Sidebum
would you choose?
Cheers Zip

[PowerBug]

With Zippy offline i'll answer these questions :D

Sidebottom has been said to be in the midfield more this season but with collingwood's small forward injury concerns, (macaffer, krakouer and didak) will he be pulled back to the forward line more?

and if so, will beams get more game time in the midfield?

I can't see the roles of Sidebottom and Beams changing too much from last year. Both will score well and you can get Sidebottom for ~70k less.

Zip

Who will most likely get the start in R1 for Dees?
Couch
Magner
Nicholson

I liked Nicholson when he played last year, was very good. And with the Dees having 3 Rookie upgrades, it won't mean that the rookies that get upgraded will be thrown straight into AFL.

To Shiel or not to Shiel? Any idea when will he be back training after the surgery??

He'll be right to go for Rd 1, and that's enough for him to be in my team. :)

[PowerBug]

I'll let Zippy answer FARK's question. :P

What are your thoughts on Mitch Robinson?
and which 3 out of....
Pav, Robinson, NRoo, Goodes, Sidebum
would you choose?
Cheers Zip

Mitch Robinson will score well, but he'll find a way to get suspended this year, unless his crashing the packs role ceases a little. So a pass for me.

I'd pick Goodes, Sidebottom and Pav coz they'll be the best scorers yet all have the same bye. So for structure Goodes, Sidebottom, NRoo.

[Ziplock]

lol. Well here's one.

Another bench forward for Tommy Walsh who doesn't have the rd 12 or 13 bye?

saying 'has a round 11 bye' would have been much clearer :P

in the mix for it... panos, kerridge, weedon, treloar, skinner, adam kennedy, cooyou, devon smith.

they all have various concerns though with either injury, scoring potential or job security. Zorko as well if named.

[Ziplock]

I dunno but my question was regarding midfield structure not forward structure... :(

in that case 3 premiums 1 mid pricer. Too many premiums in the mids will deprive you of far too much cash in a) other areas and b) for money gaining in the season.

[Ziplock]

"zip, do you wanna catch up? maybe saturday night hindley street? xx"

sorry i know it is two questions but could you please answer both

sorry bro, I live in a real state, not one deemed unfit for even convicts.

[Ziplock]

I'll let Zippy answer FARK's question. :P

What are your thoughts on Mitch Robinson?
and which 3 out of....
Pav, Robinson, NRoo, Goodes, Sidebum
would you choose?
Cheers Zip

Mitch Robinson will score well, but he'll find a way to get suspended this year, unless his crashing the packs role ceases a little. So a pass for me.

I'd pick Goodes, Sidebottom and Pav coz they'll be the best scorers yet all have the same bye. So for structure Goodes, Sidebottom, NRoo.

Similar to me, but I personally believe that Goodes won't be godlike as everyone believes in the first half of the season. I would have said, with PB's logic, Pavlich, Sidebottom and NRoo.

HOWEVER

I don't think that robinson should be left out -  he was insanely consistent, especially in the last half of the year, all he needs to do is pick up another couple of kicks and he'll be in that premium status with incredible consistency. TBH, I would say Pavlich, Sidebottom and Robinson, for scoring, value and structure.

[Ziplock]

With Zippy offline i'll answer these questions :D

Sidebottom has been said to be in the midfield more this season but with collingwood's small forward injury concerns, (macaffer, krakouer and didak) will he be pulled back to the forward line more?

and if so, will beams get more game time in the midfield?

I can't see the roles of Sidebottom and Beams changing too much from last year. Both will score well and you can get Sidebottom for ~70k less.

Zip

Who will most likely get the start in R1 for Dees?
Couch
Magner
Nicholson

I liked Nicholson when he played last year, was very good. And with the Dees having 3 Rookie upgrades, it won't mean that the rookies that get upgraded will be thrown straight into AFL.

To Shiel or not to Shiel? Any idea when will he be back training after the surgery??

He'll be right to go for Rd 1, and that's enough for him to be in my team. :)

I pretty much agree with what PB said. Beams can play as small forward, and the pies have fasolo as well. Pies have a relatively easy first half of the draw, so I think we'll be seeing some of their younger forwards be given shots against the nuff nuff teams.

as for the dees, I think all three of those are in with a shot to debut round one, possibly all 3 considering melbournes space to upgrade rookies. Their midfield is pretty poor, and their defence isn't crash hot either, so there's definitely room for all of them.

Shiel... if he's named round one, which he should be, then yes. If he's not and we don't have a definite eta on his return, then no.

[Ziplock]

In case you haven't noticed, I'm awake again and ready to answer questions :P

[Justin Bieber]

I'll let Zippy answer FARK's question. :P

What are your thoughts on Mitch Robinson?
and which 3 out of....
Pav, Robinson, NRoo, Goodes, Sidebum
would you choose?
Cheers Zip

Mitch Robinson will score well, but he'll find a way to get suspended this year, unless his crashing the packs role ceases a little. So a pass for me.

I'd pick Goodes, Sidebottom and Pav coz they'll be the best scorers yet all have the same bye. So for structure Goodes, Sidebottom, NRoo.

Similar to me, but I personally believe that Goodes won't be godlike as everyone believes in the first half of the season. I would have said, with PB's logic, Pavlich, Sidebottom and NRoo.

HOWEVER

I don't think that robinson should be left out -  he was insanely consistent, especially in the last half of the year, all he needs to do is pick up another couple of kicks and he'll be in that premium status with incredible consistency. TBH, I would say Pavlich, Sidebottom and Robinson, for scoring, value and structure.

Well I gave him the sack cause you said to get Pav :( lol, what is it?

[Justin Bieber]

Would D. Shield be playing for GWS if he wasn't picked up when he was 17?

[Justin Bieber]

Who would average better?

Rory Sloane or Chris Judd?

[Justin Bieber]

Lenny Hayes vs Michael Barlow

Swan vs Pendles

[Justin Bieber]

Which bye is the most fustrating?

Also are you even worrying about the byes???

Are you going overall or league??

Exlam cup or Champions league?


Am I getting annoying?