Rob Murphy vs Shannon Hurn vs Adcock

[The Supercoach]

If you think anyone else around this price that has a round 11 bye feel free to comment

[Ringo]

Adcock, Hanley or Scott Thompson worth consideration as well.

[The Supercoach]

adcock a good thought, i will add him to the pole. but i have never really seen thompson as a great sc scorer although his avg last year wasnt alll to bad

[tor01doc]

Suckling $1700 more than Adcock.

Murphy and Hurn a bit up and down for me.

So I won't vote in your poll. It is a free country after all...except you have to vote so I will.

Of those 3 - Add a cock.

[JamSainter]

Bob Murphy by 50 country miles!!

[Justin Bieber]

Adcock, Hanley or Scott Thompson worth consideration as well.

lol I thought you meant the other Scott Thompson, since the Norht guy never gets talked about...

[quinny88]

Such a tricky price range under 500k in the backline..
Thats why im only going with a 3 prem backline and loading my mid more.
Too much inconsistancy in the backs, including 500k+ players like broughton and birchall

[Mick Neill]

Malceski could be someone to think of.... abit of a smokie I feel.... :)

[Samm79]

In my opinion none are keepers (although I tried to make Hurn one last year!), none are cash cows. Murphy the pick of the bunch, consider Malceski as MMN suggested.

[bowyanger]

Hurn is the most durable / less likely to get injured

Hurn has still yet to reach his full potential / prime age so is progressing each year.

Hurn has a unique advantage of playing at Subi every 2nd week...same could be said for Adcock but the lions are half the team WC is which also affects confidence / performance of individual players.