Lids and rookie vs Grimes and Hargrave

[Nick_1069]

both cost about the same amount. just wondering which combo you guys think will score more? (the rookie being a guy like bugg or morris).

also do you think grimes or hargrave can be a 7th back come end of the season?

cheers

[MC]

Lids + Rookie (100+60 = 160)
Grimes + Hargrave (90+80 = 170)

Grimes and Hargrave, just! And that's dependent on your rookie choice - Could get a freak 80+ rook, but then you'd assume you'd have them anyway.

*Personal estimates obviously - not guaranteed ;)

[Justin Bieber]

Lids + Rookie (100+60 = 160)
Grimes + Hargrave (90+80 = 170)

Grimes and Hargrave, just! And that's dependent on your rookie choice - Could get a freak 80+ rook, but then you'd assume you'd have them anyway.

*Personal estimates obviously - not guaranteed ;)

What if the rookie is Dyson Heppell and ave 80?

[Nick_1069]

i donno, sounds fair enough, but i believe lids will average a bit more than 100, and im not sure if both grimes and hargrave will pay off. tough one.

[Bill Manspeaker]

Lids + Rookie for sure

that rookie should eventually become a premium anyway so you can have 100ish + 100ish = 200ish

[tor01doc]

Brad,

On his own that rookie cannot become a premium. Where does the extra money come from?

The potential reward of Grimes & Hargraves wins my vote. If one fires you are set and can sell the other. If both fire - bingo.

[Nick_1069]

will either one fire though?

[Bill Manspeaker]

2 trades, 1 rookie down and 1 rookie up.

finish your team with a team of premiums

[tor01doc]

Hope Grimes does.

He's in my team at the moment.

Lids later for me. Too many defenders with byes in round 13.

[MC]

Lids + Rookie (100+60 = 160)
Grimes + Hargrave (90+80 = 170)

Grimes and Hargrave, just! And that's dependent on your rookie choice - Could get a freak 80+ rook, but then you'd assume you'd have them anyway.

*Personal estimates obviously - not guaranteed ;)

What if the rookie is Dyson Heppell and ave 80?

If you read my full post you'd see that I covered that  8)

[Bill Manspeaker]

will either one fire though?

that's how i think aswell.. you know what you'll get if ya go 1 rookie down and 1 rookie up

[tor01doc]

I've read a couple of posts that interest me. The thrust of the argument is that 'tis a rare rookie that can hold up all season long and pump out good scores. Immature body etc etc.


Nail a couple of 'bargain' mature guys (like Grimes / Porps / Brown and a few others) at under the odds and IF they fire you save trades, get points and can go, 'Yippee' really loudly.

[MC]

The mature aged rookies led the way SC-wise last year - players like Duigan etc played consistently, and scored well. Keep that in mind when choosing your rookies, perhaps not as much emphasis on nab sc form as you'd expect.

[tor01doc]

Hey MC,

I think mcBayne has a amncrush on you.

:-*

[MC]

*Flutters eyelids*

Oh really? Haha why do you say that?