Chapman or Pavman?

[Jay]

Which of these old but bloody good forwards should be in my team? :)

[The Bomber]

im going with pavman. I had the same dilema earlier in the year, but now i have neither. only because that prem possy is filled.

I'd say pavman because he is MUCH less injury prone than chappy.

I feel they will average around the same, also geelong have a few good players that can hog the SC points, where as freo not as many...

[Cevap Roll]

I went for Pav.

But im not 100% myself, i mite swap him for Fyfe.

Not to sure about chapman i think maybe his best is past him.
IMO will struggle to score consistently above 100.

[MC]

No option for neither?

- Buddy
- Goodes
- Fyfe
- Martin
- StevieJ

All better options. Would even consider Rioli if you're that keen to take a risk eg. 32yo iffy hammies (Chappy)

[KBcokebotl]

LOL yeah dont pik Chappy if hes 32 LOL

[supercoach addict]

Age makes no difference for a player like Chappy. See Goodes or Boomer. As for his hammy's, they say that every year and then he goes out and averages 100+

[MC]

He's actually only 30 - just looked it up, but the point remains.

[Jay]

Yeah point taken fellas...cheers :)

[Ziplock]

how many other forwards are capable of averaging 110+? Chapman has to be considered. That being said, I can see pav pushing the 100+ mark this year as well. If you can fit both in....


if you can't though, I'd go pav. Less risk.