Harder to pick than a broken nose!

[ben_020285]

I have Goddard, Deledio and Shaw as my first 3 defenders, D5 is Lake at this stage. Who should I choose as D4 and why?

I can't split Fisher and Newman at the moment so convince me why I should choose one over the other!

I'm ok with getting a donut in my backline during round 13 so don't suggest a player from a different bye group, I am only asking you to choose one out of the two of them.

Cheers guys and gals..

[CrowsFan]

I would pick Newman. Had him last year and he was great before getting injured, averaging over 100.

Such a clean user of the ball so always scores well in SC :)

[Capper]

What about Birchall or Suckling??

[thatguy]

What about Birchall or Suckling??

agreed

[Fletch74]

Fisher - has the easier draw to start with

[ben_020285]

Fisher - has the easier draw to start with

Agreed that he does have an easier draw but defenders generally score better in losing teams than winning teams.

[Ringo]

If you are coping your compulsory donut in Round 13 in Defence then Newman but if you wish to avoid a prem do nut look at Broughton or Hurn

[dmac07]

Newman, classy user of the ball and rarely beaten. Fisher can have big games  but can also get taken out of it a little more than newman. Also unknown is exactly how fisher will be used under a new coach as he can play multiple roles.

[cortez]

we know where newman is playing. Midfield! get him in!!!

[The Bomber]

if you wish to avoid a prem do nut look at Broughton or Hurn

if you want to avoid the doughnut why not get Enright...Less of a risk...

Also is it worth getting Newman ahead of the 3 prems that he has (i have the same but ill have to drop one to get newman in)

[bennynam]

What about Birchall or Suckling??

agreed

+1

I'd go Birchall.

The only concern is that St.Kilda (Fisher), Richmond (Newman) and Hawthorn (Birchall) have the bye round 13.

What about Enright or Broughton?