Round 1 Captain

Started by Jacka33, February 28, 2012, 12:50:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who should you put as your captain for round 1

Scott Pendlebury (Hawthorn)
Dane Swan (Hawthorn)
Gary Ablett (Adelaide)
Adam Goodes (GWS)
Shane Mumford (GWS)
Marc Murphy (Richmond)
Bryce Gibbs (Richmond)
Scott Thompson (GCS)
Matthew Boyd (West Coast)
Dean Cox (Western Bulldogs)
Brendon Goddard (Port Adelaide)
Nick Dal Santo (Port Adelaide)
Tom Rockliff (Melbourne)
Andrew Swallow (Essendon)
Jobe Watson (North Melbourne)
Lance Franklin (Collingwood)
Trent Cotchin (Carlton)
Brett Deledio (Carlton)
Dustin Martin (Carlton)
Other - please define

Fletch74

Well, there are going to be some rookies this year, who will score just as good as a Ziebell might, like Shiels etc, so i don't think there is a concern anyway.

If they score 130+ then they'll remain my captain for Rd 1.

cortez

tht is true. personally i wont 400 or 500k sitting on my bench just in the hope that goodes or mummy can out score ablett.

Ziplock

I personally tip ziebell for a huge break out year. Unless you expect shiels to do a barlow... he's not going to outscore JZ :P

Fletch74

Quote from: Ziplock on February 28, 2012, 02:44:49 PM
I personally tip ziebell for a huge break out year. Unless you expect shiels to do a barlow... he's not going to outscore JZ :P
I'm not saying he will, but he will more than likely score 70+ Good enough for me ;)

Jacka33

Well, im guessing everyone is going with Ablett :P

meow meow

GODDARD against Port Adelaide.

Jacka33

Quote from: meow meow on February 28, 2012, 03:43:09 PM
GODDARD against Port Adelaide.

yeah its actually a good bet there, Goddard is a freak but never gets much action as captain in people's supercoach teams. He is still the most expensive defender after one of his poorer season last year.

Fletch74


supercoach addict

I got Ablett so this decision wouldn't have to be made or be as difficult.

TheMailman

Well I'd rank it this way:

1. Ablett - Scored 142 and 156 against them last year, being tagged unsuccesfully by Van Berlo and Doughty

2. Scott Thompson - If you have him, scored 151 and 135 against GC last year.

3. Goodes - Against GWS. Doubt many of them would be able to run with him for long.

Obviously Swan, Pendles, Rockliff etc. will no doubt score 100+ but I feel that those three are the ones to go with for round 1 if you have them.

I'll be going Ablett  ;)

bomberboy0618

Quote from: Ziplock on February 28, 2012, 02:44:49 PM
I personally tip ziebell for a huge break out year. Unless you expect shiels to do a barlow... he's not going to outscore JZ :P
Sloane will break out even more.
Im considering Gary Rohan as my captain to use the loophole, having Zorko on the bench. Or Sloane.

cortez

I thought zorko was going to be back for the last 1 or 2 nab games to try for a spot for round 1?

bomberboy0618

Quote from: cortez on February 28, 2012, 05:08:05 PM
I thought zorko was going to be back for the last 1 or 2 nab games to try for a spot for round 1?
I heard he had a hip injury.

cortez

i think he does. i thought he would be back for last nab game or is it going to be longer?

coconut52

Quote from: Ziplock on February 28, 2012, 02:44:49 PM
I personally tip ziebell for a huge break out year. Unless you expect shiels to do a barlow... he's not going to outscore JZ :P
is it possible to only name a vc and no c for the loophole to work