Mummy, Sandi or Cox

[underdog11]

Deciding on one of these three as my upgrade targets fr Giles, thoughts ?

[Capper]

are you starting with 1 or 2 prem rucks? If 2 then you dont want to upgrade, onbly downgrade for ca$h. if 1 then your guess is as good as mine on those 3, but cox over sandi over mummy

[Just Clancy]

shouldnt u be deciding this when u actually make the upgrade???

[Ziplock]

probably trying to decide who should be his number one ruck and who to target as an upgrade ;)

[Bak2Form]

probably trying to decide who should be his number one ruck and who to target as an upgrade ;)

+1

i got cox as my main man atm

[Justin Bieber]

I'm getting cox rd12

[egosbar]

whoever is smashing it for the right price should be your upgrade target , any performing ruck should be your upgrade target

why worry about upgrades 3 months ahead of time , the upgrade target could be injured suspended spudding it etc

worry about your run on side and the rest when you need to

you may want to hold your rookie ruck an extra week or two depending on break evens , if you upgrade ruck has a 160 score you will be wanting that to drop off before you buy

[c-hawk]

cox to sandilands saves $60 000 to upgrade any mid priced duds to premiums could mean a 10 point loss in the rucks to a 20 point gain in the fwd/backs/mids

[Capper]

cox to sandilands saves $60 000 to upgrade any mid priced duds to premiums could mean a 10 point loss in the rucks to a 20 point gain in the fwd/backs/mids

true but if you get 2 prem rucks at the start of the season (with different bye weeks) and 2 rookies then you can down grade those rookies when they hit their peak and make some decent cash if you want.

So for instance if you take Cox and Big boy (not mummy, he will get suspended) then you are set for the year and dont need to worry about trades unless you want to make some cash out of your rookies.

[c-hawk]

cox to sandilands saves $60 000 to upgrade any mid priced duds to premiums could mean a 10 point loss in the rucks to a 20 point gain in the fwd/backs/mids

true but if you get 2 prem rucks at the start of the season (with different bye weeks) and 2 rookies then you can down grade those rookies when they hit their peak and make some decent cash if you want.

So for instance if you take Cox and Big boy (not mummy, he will get suspended) then you are set for the year and dont need to worry about trades unless you want to make some cash out of your rookies.

Very true but except for the odd exception there arent many rookie rucks that make a profit - Giles will do though but would you cash in on a backup DT starting ruckman? or waste the trade if a starter goes down?

[Capper]

cox to sandilands saves $60 000 to upgrade any mid priced duds to premiums could mean a 10 point loss in the rucks to a 20 point gain in the fwd/backs/mids

true but if you get 2 prem rucks at the start of the season (with different bye weeks) and 2 rookies then you can down grade those rookies when they hit their peak and make some decent cash if you want.

So for instance if you take Cox and Big boy (not mummy, he will get suspended) then you are set for the year and dont need to worry about trades unless you want to make some cash out of your rookies.

Very true but except for the odd exception there arent many rookie rucks that make a profit - Giles will do though but would you cash in on a backup DT starting ruckman? or waste the trade if a starter goes down?

depend on when the prem went down but i would probably do a double trade depending on the injury (rookie for cash, prem to prem) if it was after the byes) if before the byes would see how Giles is going but depending on the injury Prem to a prem

[Windigo]

Wasn't there a question the exact same as this?  :P

[elephants]

Mummy for the huge scores coupled with the crap ones.

Sandi for 19 games of 95 ave.

Coxy for the best ruckmen in the game.