Giles?

[t-rent]

a lot of people are going this guy this year.....im considering him but is he really going to average a good amount of points each game in a young team with brogan by his side?

[bomberboy0618]

Look at Smith. Smith averaged really well in a team that came last, with Fraser and Brogan. All at age 18. Now Giles is mature age, with the same situation. I reckon he can do it. And then some.

[TheMailman]

You look at Brogan, as much respect for him as I have he's not really up to the same standard as other rucks which is understandable due to his age etc.

Giles will get many games and probably won't hit a wall like Smith did

[DT-SC]

but smith is 23-ish now

[TheMailman]

but smith is 23-ish now

Smith is 22 and Giles is 24?

[Justin Bieber]

but smith is 23-ish now

Just turned 22 so he was 21 last year... and he was also a twig haha

[Pokerface]

You look at Brogan, as much respect for him as I have he's not really up to the same standard as other rucks which is understandable due to his age etc.

Giles will get many games and probably won't hit a wall like Smith did

He would be up to their standard if he was still at Port...

[elephants]

Smith was also mature BB :P

I can start Giles but I have 350k in the bank so it is too easy to turn him into Mummy before round 1.

[TheMailman]

Difference between 19 and 22 isn't all that much  :P

[chatters24]

There should be no disputing how valuable Giles will be as a 3rd/4th ruckman. As a 2nd ruckman, well that could be another story..

[elephants]

There should be no disputing how valuable Giles will be as a 3rd/4th ruckman. As a 2nd ruckman, well that could be another story..

True, could also be the difference between a top 500 finish and a 20,000+. If it comes off you are in the box seat. If not, it is a long road back...

[Justin Bieber]

There should be no disputing how valuable Giles will be as a 3rd/4th ruckman. As a 2nd ruckman, well that could be another story..

True, could also be the difference between a top 500 finish and a 20,000+. If it comes off you are in the box seat. If not, it is a long road back...

If you make the mistake of having Giles as number 2 (so hegoes down in the first rd), it's not going to make you come 20,000 for it.

[Windigo]

Damn I'm sick of ruck talk.

Teams look 'better' with Giles as number two. That's an easy one.

But how will it look if Giles/your number one ruck goes down and your two dodgy ruck back ups aren't playing.

[Windigo]

Don't think it means much coming from my friend....

He was at the game he said Orren has no tank?  ??? Said he "huffing & puffing" after like 5 minutes?  :P

[Justin Bieber]

The Big O looked good on the weekend. The commentators loved him.