rate a top 500 2011 coach ;)

[love it]

12,800 in bank

Backs

Goddard, Enright, shaw, Deledio, Bugg (GWS), Townsend (GWS) Wilson (wce) Morris (rich), Brennan J (wce)

Mids
Swan, Boyd, Ablett, Mitchell, Selwood, Neale (freo), McDonald (GWS), Magner (Melb)

Rucks

Cox, Mumford, Giles (GWS), Stephensen (Gee)

Forwards

Chapman, Franklin, Pavlich, Saad (st Kilda), Horlin - smith (Gee), Bruce (GWS), Weedon (Wce), Treloar (GWS), Hall (GC)


Obviously at this stage none of the rookies are lock and will wait untill the round one teams are announced. but would be looking to swap one of the Round 11 rookies in the back lines for a round 12 rookie in the back. as ive decided to try and go with a premiums that will be in the top 10 at the end of the season, while still only getting 1-2 zeros in the bye weeks, and obviously rookies that should have the best job security and start at the 100k mark rather than the 170k while still having the same risk

If there are any rookies you would definatly not reccomend due to possible injury concerns or job security (realise Horlin smith will struggle for a game even if he did kill it today as its geelong/ still have doubts over morris) or anything else that would be great

[Memphistopheles]

Not sure Wilson and Brennan will get too much game time for West Coast. I'd be looking elsewhere for def rookies. L Brown from Adelaide perhaps?

Also I think Smedts is a better option for a Geelong rookie than Horlin-Smith and you could get him in either your backs or forwards.

Wheedon is not a lock for West Coast either. By all reports he looked a little unfit in the NAB Cup despite doing well and if he plays he would be my pick to get the green vest for quite a few games.

Finally I'm not sure you want to start with five prem mids - the mid rookies are the best ones. Downgrade a prem to another rookie and upgrade a rookie back and/or forward.

[Justin Bieber]

I don't want to get hated here, but your forward line is horrible.