could you please rate my team!

[JamesHarden13]

Backs; Goddard, Shaw, Birchall, Hanley, Lake, Bugg, Morris (L.Brown, B.Wilkes)

Mids; Pendlebury, Ablett, Murphy, Rockliff, Melksham, Horsley (Magner, Gibson)

Rucks; Leunberger, Giles (Rowe, Stephenson)

Forwards; Buddy, Pavlich, Martin, Dangerfield, Brown, Smedts, T.Walsh (Panos, Kerridge)

$7100 left in the bank.

thoughts on what i could do to improve my team are greatly appreciated! even a rate would be good.

Cheers!

[quinny88]

solid side but i would consider these adjustments..
downgrade pendles to someone like selwood (saves 100k) you can always upgrade later when his price drops.
downgrade melksham to a rook (saves 200k)
downgrade jbrown to a rook (saves 200k)

use the savings to swap one of your rookie rucks for a mumford or sandilands type.
super important to have 2 good scorers in the ruck

[Big_Cox14]

Backs: Pretty strong there in structure. I'm personally not sold on Lake myself but you have your reasons for picking him.

Mids: Again very strong midfield there. Which would explain why not a lot of money has been spent on the rucks. Melksham could be a nice unique mid pricer. Was one of the best against the eagles. I like the mature age rookie choices and think if given a chance that they will all fire!

Rucks: Not a structure that I'm employing for my team (I'm going 2 prems on field, 2 rooks on bench). I want to go for the best from the start and minimise the use of trades in the rucks. Though, with your structure you've chosen the rooks with the best chance of playing plus a decent #1 ruck.

For: Bit less depth than mids and defenders. Though, a good mix of guns, couple of calculated risks in mid pricers and good rooks.

Overall, I've got to say that there are a good mix of guns and rooks with a few calculated mid pricers for a point of difference.

It's an 8/10 for me.

[johnnytheboy1]

Back  The defense is fairly solid but i would look at replacing one of Hanley or Lake as they are not going to score highly.But that is up to you.
MIDS You have a good structure here of premium rookies and the unique pick of Melksham.
Rucks: This is where you are going to lose points to the teams that have 2 premium rucks.
Fwds A good mix of premiums.Mid priced & Rookie forwards. I like the select of Dangerfield and he will have a break out year.

Overall i give your team an 8/10