Could you please rate my team??

Started by Degsman, February 25, 2012, 07:49:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Degsman

First time putting a team together so I am looking for some feedback (:

DEF: B. Goddard (mid) , B. Deledio (mid) , H. Shaw, M. Clarke, B. Ellis, T. Bugg, S. Darley (L. Brown(mid), M. Baguley(mid))
MID: G. Ablett jnr, M. Murphy, M. Priddis, J. Selwood, D. Pfeiffer(fwd), S. Reid (L. Neale, S. Gibson)
RUC: S. Mumford, M. Leuenberger (J. Giles, O. Stephenson)
FWD: L. Franklin, A. Goodes(mid), N. Fyfe(mid), D. Martin(mid), J. Brown, R. Cooyou, B. Smedts(def) (A. Treloar(mid), D.Zorko(mid)
CASH LEFT: $9,400

Thank-you!!

quinny88

perfect side appart from the backline obviously being a little light.. i understand you have chosen to go with a 3 prem and 4 rook option in the back and i like that idea as there arent that many appealing backs who you can rely on this year to be consistant other than the ones you have and scotland and maybe fisher aswell.
j.brown? not to sure on him. hes your only risk, may aswell downgrade to a rook and turn priddis or jelwood into a dane swan or pendles

9/10

JamSainter

Love it Degsman!! Mainly because you have the exact same structure as me!!  :o

Spite

Besides S.Reid in the mid, maybe go someone more reliable like mcdonald? Loving Priddis, great unqiue there!
Overall an excellent team :)

Degsman

Thanks guys :)

quinny88, I like your thinking, I understand that my backline is a bit light on, but as you say there really aren't any reliable backs ): I will probably have to look at upgrading early in my backline to get a better balance :) As for J.brown, At this moment in time I am willing to take the risk :)

JamSainter, Thanks man!!

Spite, Thank-you :) at the moment I think a few of my rookies will likely change around a bit and so I will look at changing Reid :)

johnnytheboy1

Backs Are a bit lite but you should be able to make up for this in other areas.
Mids  I would replace Reid With Magner of Melbourne. apart from that you have a Solid midfield.
Rucks I would lock those two in 2 premium 2 rookies is the way to go.
FWDS I see your set at keeping JBROWN in your team i hope it pays off for you.
I give your team an 8.5/10

Degsman

What do you recommend if I get rid of J.Brown?? as in what should I then use the money on??