K Lucas anyone?

[tor01doc]

Any reason not to get him?

Cheers.

[verda32]

How will he get the ball? With Gibbs, Murphy, Carrazzo, Judd, Simpson, Robinson etc getting the ball before him. Will struggle to make best 22

[ando_10]

How will he get the ball? With Gibbs, Murphy, Carrazzo, Judd, Simpson, Robinson etc getting the ball before him. Will struggle to make best 22

hmmm unsure how ya can make that assumption when he has only played a hand full of games. who knows with a proper pre season and hes fully fit his locked in for me.

[tor01doc]

Love the 2 replies thus far.

Yes and no.

Leaves me with I don't know!

[TheMailman]

How will he get the ball? With Gibbs, Murphy, Carrazzo, Judd, Simpson, Robinson etc getting the ball before him. Will struggle to make best 22

hmmm unsure how ya can make that assumption when he has only played a hand full of games. who knows with a proper pre season and hes fully fit his locked in for me.

I'm sorry but that's a pretty dodgy reply. Carlton have arguably the best midfield in the comp and I highly doubt that Lucas will be getting much game time.

With players competing to get into the midfield like Ellard and Curnow I can't see how Lucas can get ahead of them

No

[BGK]

How will he get the ball? With Gibbs, Murphy, Carrazzo, Judd, Simpson, Robinson etc getting the ball before him. Will struggle to make best 22

hmmm unsure how ya can make that assumption when he has only played a hand full of games. who knows with a proper pre season and hes fully fit his locked in for me.

I'm sorry but that's a pretty dodgy reply. Carlton have arguably the best midfield in the comp and I highly doubt that Lucas will be getting much game time.

With players competing to get into the midfield like Ellard and Curnow I can't see how Lucas can get ahead of them

No

I agree with Mailman. Locked in is a pretty bold statement when you haven't even seen if he is in the best 22.

[ando_10]

How will he get the ball? With Gibbs, Murphy, Carrazzo, Judd, Simpson, Robinson etc getting the ball before him. Will struggle to make best 22

hmmm unsure how ya can make that assumption when he has only played a hand full of games. who knows with a proper pre season and hes fully fit his locked in for me.

I'm sorry but that's a pretty dodgy reply. Carlton have arguably the best midfield in the comp and I highly doubt that Lucas will be getting much game time.

With players competing to get into the midfield like Ellard and Curnow I can't see how Lucas can get ahead of them

No

maybe so fellas but still hes been blitzing time trails and been really impressive in intra club matches from all reports.

theres only one way to find out. and that this weekend in the nab cup.

[BGK]

How will he get the ball? With Gibbs, Murphy, Carrazzo, Judd, Simpson, Robinson etc getting the ball before him. Will struggle to make best 22

hmmm unsure how ya can make that assumption when he has only played a hand full of games. who knows with a proper pre season and hes fully fit his locked in for me.

I'm sorry but that's a pretty dodgy reply. Carlton have arguably the best midfield in the comp and I highly doubt that Lucas will be getting much game time.

With players competing to get into the midfield like Ellard and Curnow I can't see how Lucas can get ahead of them

No

maybe so fellas but still hes been blitzing time trails and been really impressive in intra club matches from all reports.

theres only one way to find out. and that this weekend in the nab cup.

Even if he tears this weekend up i wont be paying too much attention. I really don't rate the kick and giggle. I will wait and see what happens in the other three weeks.

[TheMailman]

Intra Club matches mean little and less.

I know that TDL scored 7 goals in the 2011 Swans Intra-Club match and didn't play any games because he couldn't beat others

[j959]

How will he get the ball? With Gibbs, Murphy, Carrazzo, Judd, Simpson, Robinson etc getting the ball before him. Will struggle to make best 22

hmmm unsure how ya can make that assumption when he has only played a hand full of games. who knows with a proper pre season and hes fully fit his locked in for me.

I'm sorry but that's a pretty dodgy reply. Carlton have arguably the best midfield in the comp and I highly doubt that Lucas will be getting much game time.

With players competing to get into the midfield like Ellard and Curnow I can't see how Lucas can get ahead of them

No

maybe so fellas but still hes been blitzing time trails and been really impressive in intra club matches from all reports.

theres only one way to find out. and that this weekend in the nab cup.

ando, that description sounds like Chris Masten of previous pre-seasons (and incidentally this one as well I believe) ...  ;)

but seriously, it's a monitoring thing and this is why it is very hard to pick the mid-pricer break-out candidates ...

[n4cr123]

He will have to absolutely explode in the nab form e to consider him... Even then, I can see a vest or 2 for him...

[youl_R_FCK]

He is favourt if not second favouret for Rising star, so there must be good signs behind closed doors

[TheMailman]

He is favourt if not second favouret for Rising star, so there must be good signs behind closed doors

No way. Although he just qualifies to be eligible for the award there is no way he'll play enough games to be an option