PRETTY HAPPY WITH THIS ONE!

Started by quinny88, February 23, 2012, 02:04:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

quinny88

NEW TEAM! only posting my on field players as my rookies will change at the end of the nab cup.. give me your scores and thoughts!

BACKS: B.GODDARD, B.DELEDIO, H.SHAW, S.HURN, B.LAKE, M.CLARKE, S.MORRIS

MIDS G.ABLETT, M.MURPHY, M.BOYD, J.SELWOOD, J.MCDONALD, TOM MITCHELL

RUCK M.LEUENBERGER, M.KREUZER

FRWD L.FRANKLIN, N.FYFE, D.MARTIN, N.RIEWOLDT, J.PORPLYZIA, D.ZORKO, A.TREAOLAR

ben_020285

Nice side.

I would just downgrade Porps to a rookie and upgrade Kreuzer to McEvoy. Lake and Riewoldt both risks but NAB cup form should be a good guide as to whether they will play well this season.

8/10

quinny88

yea i really want to wait and see on lake and porps. i dont think roo is as bigger risk as people think. if you look at his previous 6 seasons prior to last year he averaged 110+ i think he will bounce back

Torress

i understand its a rookie and it'll change but zorko is unlikely round 1 mate. i think he could be a good downgrade early on.

- don't get caught up with hurn's game in the NAB mate!! he had no one on him. he is up and down but that being said i've been sucked in b4!

also tom mitchell is unlikely round 1 as well.

be mindful of the rucks you've picked, leuy has hudson to contend and kreuz has warnock and hampson - and kreuz's role will change. mind you he is under priced but i don't think he'll push for top5 rucks overall.

yea Nroo is an interesting one, i'm not going there. just not at all!!  - no browndawg??? i'd swap Nroo for Jono brown personally. Jroo is underpriced could be a good pick but hard start of season for tiges and you have dusty martin in there already.

but mate solid prems, i reckon you could start one more rookie somewhere and upgrade an ''iffy'' pick to a solid prem.
good luck digger

quinny88

Quote from: Torress on February 23, 2012, 03:25:32 PM
i understand its a rookie and it'll change but zorko is unlikely round 1 mate. i think he could be a good downgrade early on.

- don't get caught up with hurn's game in the NAB mate!! he had no one on him. he is up and down but that being said i've been sucked in b4!

also tom mitchell is unlikely round 1 as well.

be mindful of the rucks you've picked, leuy has hudson to contend and kreuz has warnock and hampson - and kreuz's role will change. mind you he is under priced but i don't think he'll push for top5 rucks overall.

yea Nroo is an interesting one, i'm not going there. just not at all!!  - no browndawg??? i'd swap Nroo for Jono brown personally. Jroo is underpriced could be a good pick but hard start of season for tiges and you have dusty martin in there already.

but mate solid prems, i reckon you could start one more rookie somewhere and upgrade an ''iffy'' pick to a solid prem.
good luck digger

Yea im iffy on hurn but im not sure who else to go in that price range.
Rucks were based on the fact that leunberger dominated towards the end of last season and kreuzer is fit and firing so should go up a few notches.
I cant see browny getting back to his best.. Plays in an ordinary side and has no clarke or staker there so he will be double teamed if he can remain un injured. And jroo.. Im a richmond supporter and love him but theres to many quiet games that will hurt me by him

ChinKing

team is shaping nicely. only change i would make is downgrade porpis and then upgrade riewoldt otherwise strong

Fistipumper

Mate I reckon N Reiwolt is very much overlooked this year, maybe people to quick to forget. I like this side but one thing would concern me, S Hurn seemed to go missing abit last year not sure it could be me just me. Other than that I like the way you roll.     excellent choice of premo mids  ;)

quinny88

Quote from: Fistipumper on February 23, 2012, 07:34:06 PM
Mate I reckon N Reiwolt is very much overlooked this year, maybe people to quick to forget. I like this side but one thing would concern me, S Hurn seemed to go missing abit last year not sure it could be me just me. Other than that I like the way you roll.     excellent choice of premo mids  ;)

Who is a good option instead of hurn? That price range is a tricky one

Fistipumper

yeah I, atm, have godd, lids, fisher, grimes, lake for mine. If you don't rate Grimes or trust him to not get injured, Heppel maybe an option, effective user and seems to be in every thing

Ringo

Nice team.

Suggestion to replace Hurn at similar price and may give you a unique is Burgoyne,  Has the skills and will get possessions with the hawks playing style.  Heppell is another option if you can afford him.

Brown will improve as Brisbane's improving midfield will give him better service. Brisbane also have alternate talls down forward with Lisle, Karnezis and Cornelius and if they fire will draw defenders from Brown.
Rate your team 8/10

bennynam

#10
Quote from: quinny88 on February 23, 2012, 02:04:18 PM
NEW TEAM! only posting my on field players as my rookies will change at the end of the nab cup.. give me your scores and thoughts!

BACKS: B.GODDARD, B.DELEDIO, H.SHAW, S.HURN, B.LAKE, M.CLARKE, S.MORRIS

MIDS G.ABLETT, M.MURPHY, M.BOYD, J.SELWOOD, J.MCDONALD, TOM MITCHELL

RUCK M.LEUENBERGER, M.KREUZER

FRWD L.FRANKLIN, N.FYFE, D.MARTIN, N.RIEWOLDT, J.PORPLYZIA, D.ZORKO, A.TREAOLAR
Posting a side without your rookies (bench) is like cooking bacon and eggs without the bacon!

Obese Arachnid

Quote from: Ringo on February 26, 2012, 07:43:03 PM
Nice team.

Suggestion to replace Hurn at similar price and may give you a unique is Burgoyne,  Has the skills and will get possessions with the hawks playing style.  Heppell is another option if you can afford him.

Brown will improve as Brisbane's improving midfield will give him better service. Brisbane also have alternate talls down forward with Lisle, Karnezis and Cornelius and if they fire will draw defenders from Brown.
Rate your team 8/10

Not sure I'd call Karnezis a tall. From memory he's as tall as Pendles, who admittedly is tall for a mid. Cornelius is still pretty raw, a good honest defender with third man up should cover him. Brown to me looks somewhat exposed, so i'm giving him a pass.

Cotter101

Quote from: quinny88 on February 23, 2012, 11:48:37 PM

Who is a good option instead of hurn? That price range is a tricky one

Pearce Hanley looks set to pay a fair bit of midfield time. He would probably be a better option than Hurn.