4 midfield elites too much?

Started by Birryfy, February 22, 2012, 11:15:08 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Birryfy

4 mid elites too much do you think? Pendles, Abblet, Murphy and Selwood. The area that is affected is rucks, having Luey and Hmac.. thoughts on this idea?

Jimbo_11

personally, ive gone with 3 mids because i believe that the best rooks are in the mids and that when it comes time to upgrading them, you can choose the mids who are playing the best and not waste a trade on changing premiums for premiums. also allows you to have 5 backs 2 rucks and 5 fwds, which i have, and also allows for more flexibility, if you put dpp rooks in mids and a better choice of rooks

Mozza3

Not at all. I'm running 4 premo mids but its just  a case of personal preference. Just like the ruck structure argument................

specky lecky

I agree with Jimbo. All the best rookies, the ones who's prices will appreciate the most, are all midfielders. Limit yourself to three premium mids, maybe one breakout mid like sloane, caddy, masten etc, then have the rest as cheap mids. Upgrade in time for the byes.

elephants

Nope. I have four and am considering a 5th with midfield options dropping left right and centre.

yorgis

can' t see any of those dropping form nor some of the others, thommo,swan, boyd, gibbs, judd. i think only LTI

would force you to sideways trade. you generally have to make 2 trades to get 1 of these fellas in [ 1downgrade and 1

upgrade]

Jukes

I've got Swan, Ablett, Boyd and Selwood. Mids you should go all out on.

mezzoculo

Quote from: Jukes on February 23, 2012, 02:54:12 PM
I've got Swan, Ablett, Boyd and Selwood. Mids you should go all out on.
+1.
Having these mids lets me start with a third DPP forward with the Rnd 13 bye (Martin) and gives me the chance to upgrade a mid rookie to one of Rocky/Swallow/Redden/Thompson when I have the cash.

PowerBug

Quote from: Jukes on February 23, 2012, 02:54:12 PM
I've got Swan, Ablett, Boyd and Selwood. Mids you should go all out on.
Sorta like my mids. :) 4 super-premo's is fine.

BillyBass

I've gone with 4 elites, as well as 2 premium rucks. Skimping a bit on the fwds/backs, just aren't enough options that I like there at this stage.

Jukes

I've changed mine to Swanny, GAJ, Rocky, Boyd and Stanton now. Much better.

Flame


elephants

Swan OR Selwood, Pendles, Ablett, Murphy for me...

PowerBug

Quote from: Jukes on February 25, 2012, 01:58:57 AM
I've changed mine to Swanny, GAJ, Rocky, Boyd and Stanton now. Much better.
Just the casual 5 premium mids first up.

elephants

I looked at that option PB but my team is better with a four premo mid. Your team might be better with 5 though. Personal preference really...