Caddy vs. Wingard

[Jay]

caddy vs. wingard

[sid3bysid3]

Neither, but if you insist on spending extra on rookies then wingard

[kilbluff1985]

Neither

Caddy to expensive

Primus said in an article Wingard wont get much game time needs more match fitness

[Mozza3]

Caddy has got the extra year under his belt, Wingaard sounds promising but I'd rather go and pick someone a lot cheaper.

[CrowsFan]

I agree with the neither statement by the other 2.

As they had already said caddy is too expensive, he's over 200k isn't he? And Primus has said Wingard isn't fit enough yet.

Save the cash and get cheapo rookies who will score just as well ;)

[Jay]

Put it this way...need someone with a rnd 13 bye who is less than 217.5k! Already have horsley and neale. Also pfieffer in my forwards

[Mozza3]

There's a guy from St. Kilda who tagged Goddard in the intra-club and did well, forgot his name.

[mdub]

caddy for sure. player easy to use to upgrade to a premium. he'll defently have a price increase of 150-200k. and hes been sent to arizona with 3 others. hes defelty going to put straight into rd1 team. and essedon wer going to give gold coast an arm and leg for caddy in trade week.

[Colliwobblers]

im running caddy, altitude training as we speak, the guy is a freak, he will play every game, he will have elite fitness he already had elite skills, working with the master in the GCS midfield, 70 - 80 i reckon easily and for $218,200 will make it to 400K and be upgraded to a my 6th premium after the byes some time.

or play it safe get a 113k rookie and trade him in at 250k

[Jay]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,48921.0.html

Made a new thread, bit more in depth and relevant to my team becuae i just found out i am $800 short of caddy -_-

[Bill Manspeaker]

There's a guy from St. Kilda who tagged Goddard in the intra-club and did well, forgot his name.

Seb Ross, St Kilda's first pick in the draft

he should get games, but it's hard to tell if Watters will blood the first year players or not. i think he will and hope he does as a Saints supporter

[Mozza3]

Cheers brad, sounds rather promising.