Post Up Your Team And I'll Leave My Thoughts!

[dtrain]

hey windy settle on my team i recken, what do u think, cheers bro

back: b.goddard a.carrazzo b.deledio g.birchall b.waters r.hargrave b.ellis (s.morris t.bugg)

mids: m.boyd g,ablett s.pendlebury s.thompson w.hoskin-elloitt s.coniglio (j.mcdonald j.magner)

ruck: d.coxs  j.giles (j.redden o.stephenson)

fwd: l.franklin n.fyfe s.sidebottom p.dangerfield  j.porplyzia d.smith a.kennedy (g.weeden  a.hall)

$37,900 left

[Windigo]

BigHeat:

BACKS:

Solid line mate. Dunno about Smedts' job security however.

MIDS:

Excelent top 4. Keep Clifton, should play all games and Palmer wasn't their to help him yesterday. Rookie selections may come back to hurt you. Kerridge always subbed and Miles 'not in the best 22.'

RUCKS:

Share the same bye. Watch out.

FORWARDS:

Very close to my FWD line.  :o. Great line and Dazza P should play most games, but don't expect big things from him.

OVERALL:

A very solid team and there aren't many weaknessess. Perhaps your rookie options in the midfield?

Don't trade Birch. Sidebum will come close to scoring the same as Pav. Keep it as is.  ;)

[Windigo]

Muddy79:

BACKS:

Very strong line. Docherty didn't play and I think Golby may be keeping him out. Guthrie was impressive without scoring heavily and should play round one. Very nice line mate.  :)

MIDS:

Don't think having Shuey is the correct option this year. Maybe next year. T-Rock should slay this year.

RUCKS:

They share the same bye.....

FORWARDS:

I think Danger is worth a shot this year with his impressive pre-season. Solid rookies.

OVERALL:

Good team mate. Maybe the midfield has to be tweaked a bit. Get 4 premiums in there. But Shoe could explode, but not for me. Adjust the rucks for the bye.  ;)

[Windigo]

Brenny G:

BACKS:

Solid backline. Waters impressed last night and seems to be a viable option. I'd rather a rookie to lake. Or Hargrave?

MIDS:

I wouldn't have Pavlich in the midfield. Put him FWD! Hayes is way too risky and Gaff is at an awkward price...

RUCKS:

Share the same bye....

FORWARDS:

I'd oust Motlop and Darling. Get Pavlich in here and downgrade Darling to rookie and upgrade in the midfield.

OVERALL:

An okay team but the midfield is all over the shop. I'd look to strengthen it up and get Pavlich FORWARD!  :)

[Windigo]

AFLhanger:

BACKS:

Your missing a back? Solid line from what I see.  ;)

MIDS:

Great midfield. Your like the second person behind me to have Redden! Caddy is looking alright, but I'd rather a rookie at 5.

RUCKS:

Good. They share the same bye.

FORWARDS:

Missing a FWD here too mate. Ultra strong the way it though. Maybe too strong. Cash can be freed up if you downgrade Stevie to Martin?

OVERALL:

Good side. Just missing a couple of players? Pretty strong the way it is.  :)

[hawkhead]

Defenders
B.Goddard, H.Shaw, G.Broughton, B.Waters,  N.Malceski,  B.Ellis, T.Bugg, (S.Darley, S.Morris)

Midfielders
G.Ablett, S.Mitchell, N.Fyfe, B.Deledio, C.Ward, J.Caddy, (S.Kerridge, J.McDonald)

Rucks

S.Mumford, J.Giles, (J.Redden, O.Stephenson)

Forwards

L.Franklin, M.Pavlich, D.Martin, C.Rioli, P.Dangerfield, D.Smith, S.Saad, (A.Kennedy, G.Weedon)

Rookies will  depend on lineups in round 1, but these are my first thoughts

[Tittan99]

Backs:
H. Scotland, B. Goddard, G. Broughton, M. Suckling, B. Deledio, M. Clarke, B. Ellis
S. Morris, T. Bugg

Midfield:
D. Swan, G. Ablett (vc), M. Boyd (c), L. Sumner, J. McDonald, D. Shiels
D. Pefieffer, J, Magnar

Rucks:
S. Mumford, H. McIntosh
J. Gilles, J. Redden

Forwards:
P. Chapman, L. Franklin, N. Fyfe, D. Martin, S. Sidebottom, D. Smith, A. Treloar
A. Hall, B. Smedts

$13,600 left

[Windigo]

Barra:

BACKS:

Pretty solid mate. Needs a mid-pricer perhaps?  ???

MIDS:

Strong as! Coniglio looks a safe option. Maybe bot Shiel, don't think he'll play round one.

RUCKS:

They share the same bye.....

FORWARDS:

Bit light on with with 3 rookies starting. Rookie options a worry as well.

OVERALL:

Quality team. Since you've gone with the two ruck premo strategy your gunna be a bit light on in other areas. Really cannot have two rucks from the same bye. Good side, but some of your rookie selections have to be dealt with.

[Windigo]

Ago97:

BACKS:

Pretty sold backline. I prefer 4 premium defenders....But Broughton could be that this year....Or not. Solid. Don't think Smedts is the best option.

MIDS:

Don't think you have the best rookie options....Miles is a good player, but it seems Sheeds doesn't like him. Kerridge is always sub, but will get game time....2nd person I've seen with Redden. Good work.  :)

RUCKS:

Standard. Massive Cox is just dominant.

FORWARDS:

Pretty good line mate. Actually, it's very good indeed. Never been a fan of Dangerfield. But I can see why people are getting him in.

OVERALL:

A well though out squad with your FWD line being a highlight. Maybe make sure your rookies are playing, but it's very good.  8)

[footyman]

back: goddard, shaw, delidio, birchall, lake, clarke, b.ellis (smedts, t.bugg)

mids: s.pendlebury, boyd, ablett, selwood, coniglio, c.smith (clifton, j.magner)

ruck: sandi, j.giles (j.redden, o.stephenson)

fwd: l.franklin, n.fyfe, d.martin, s.sidebottom, gray, d.smith, pfeiffer (hall, hampton)

What do you think about my team?

[Windigo]

HammertimeMRD:

BACKS:

Pretty line here mate. I'd suggest an alternative option to Enright. Injured and is past his best footy for DT, IMO.

MIDS:

Who is Young? Keep Clifton, think he should average pretty good and won't be out of the squad as he is mature age and a tough body for GWS. Few unique options, not bad.  ;)

RUCKS:

Ryder? Now that is different, has done pretty well in the pre-season. Certainly will give you some P.O.D if he fires.  ;)

FORWARDS:

Brown is out for the first couple of games.....Izzy really shouldn't be in your team. Solid, get rid of JB.

OVERALL:

Pretty good team here. A few unique choices. I'd consider ousting Brown>Rookie and upgrading somewhere else. Keep Clifton,  ;).

[Windigo]

Hally25547:

BACKS:

Personally, I'd rather Deledio. I'm not a fan of Birchall, has one good season in the past 4. All in the 70's. Get Deledio. Id rather Hargrave. I wouldn't have both Dogs.

MIDS:

Hm, might be missing another premium here. Rookies all good though. Dunno if Miles will play round one however.   ;)

RUCKS:

Dominance. But would Giles & premium mid be better?  :o

FORWARDS:

Quality FWD line mate. Dunno about Smedts or Hall at this stage. Wait for teams I guess.

OVERALL

Really good side. Only I'd downgrade Lake and get another premium in the midfield?

[Windigo]

mmurphy3:


BACKS:

Solid backline. Broughton has been impressing in the NAB and could up the average. But this is without a few first choice midfield options....

MIDS:

Red-Rock combo. Love it.  8) Watch the rookies, but yeah good line mate.

RUCKS:

Standard. Cox should slay.

FORWARDS:

Solid line again mate. I'd use the extra cash and get Danger in there maybe?

OVERALL:

Really nice team mate. Plenty of cash, I'd use in on some of your rookies are to get another FWD like Danger?

[Windigo]

WP Wingnuts:

BACKS:

Solid. Broughton has been slaying pre-season. But I think he will still have a few games where he will be pretty shower. Good to see Guthrie in there. I rate him, has been starved of opportunities and impressed in the last NAB without accumating possessions.

MIDS:

Big fan of Andy Swallow, I think he will be going places this year. Dunno about Hogan though. Didn't play in the last game may mean hi isn't in there best 22.

RUCKS:

Standard setup.

FORWARDS:

I think the Pav-Fyfe combo can work a treat this year. Dangerfield has been slaying and could step it up this year. I'm considering him, against my better judgment!  :P

OVERALL:

Really nice team mate. Well thought out, you've certainty done some research into this. Re-think the Hogan choice if he ain't named round one. 

[Windigo]

The Mailman:

BACKS:

Solid top 4. Dunno if Darley & Bugg can play together in the same team.

MIDS:

Pretty strong. Murphy is a bit unique. Miles not playing this week means he must be ousted. Not in the best 22 apparently.

RUCKS:

Standard ruck options.

FORWARDS:

Robbo looks a good unique pick up as we haven't really seen much of him this year yet. Looked okay today. Zorko is injured and I wouldn't think he would play round one. Curtly looked okay playing as a FWD. Too bad the GWS mids couldn't deliver it to him.  :P

OVERALL:

As you said, pretty general team. But it's safe way to tackle things. I have'nt much to say, as it is pretty good. I think you'll find I comment more on the teams that have a few genuine left field options. As I like teams that have a few risks.

Good team mate.  :)