Post Up Your Team And I'll Leave My Thoughts!

[jacksonmcguire]

Would appreciate some feedback/advice.. Pretty happy with this though.

Backs: Goddard, Deledio, H Shaw, Broughton, M Clarke, B Ellis, T Bugg (Sierakowski, Morris)
Mids: Swan, Pendlebury, Ablett, Boyd, Wingard, D Shiel (T Mitchell, Magner)
Rucks: Cox, McIntosh (Giles, Stephensen)
Forwards: Franklin, S Johnson, Fyfe, D Martin, Byrnes, Saad, Treloar (Smedts, D Smith)
$35,700 leftover
Cheers

[Windigo]

I'll do these tomorrow.

SAC's left right and center.  :P

[Spite]

I am in a very competitive league and need some help.

Sloane or Barlow or Dangerfield?

My FWDS are set in concrete.

Team:
BACKS: Goddard, Enright, Delidio, Waters, M Clarke, B Ellis, Bugg (Spurr, Brown)

RUCKS: Cox, MacIntosh (Giles, Stephenson)

MIDS: Pendlebury, Boyd, Abblett, Murphy, Sloane/Barlow/Danderfield, Shiel (McDonald, Mitchell)

$5,300 Left

Cheers

He will say Sloane, and I too say sloane :P

Waters may be a bit of a dodgy pick, his elbow was still troubling him early this year and he has had surgery multiple times on it... not a good omen! Do what you can to trade him out :)

[brodman_18]

$84 700 in the bank

Goddard, Delidio, Broughton, Heppell, Golby, Ellis, Darley
(Mohr, Bugg)

Swan, Mitchell, J Selwood, Hayes, Miles, McDonald
(Shiel, Kerridge)

Luenburger, McEvoy (Giles, Stephenson)

Johnson, Franklin, Beams, Martin, Porplyzia, D Smith, Horlin-Smith
(Saad, Cameron)

[Windigo]

Dutchie64:

BACKS:

Probably needs another premium back. Rolling with Adcock at 3 is just asking for trouble. Needs much needed gunning up. Hargrave looks good so far!

MIDS:

Very strong. Personally I prefer 4 mid premiums and then two rookies/rookie priced players. You'd be hoping Sloane can smash out tons this year. Could happen.

RUCKS:

Dominant. Big Cox should smash it up early.

FORWARDS:

Strong. Chappy should be a good unique pick this year. Nice line mate. Maybe oust Weedon.  ;)

OVERALL:

Great looking team, I think the backs are bit light on. But you've gone with an extra mid. I wouldn't do that way. But your in with pretty good shot in your league the way it is. Watch the byes though!  ;)

[Windigo]

Arzbarz96:

BACKS:

Good top 3. Not keen on Adcock this year. He provided good value in 2011. But it's 2012. I'd go for Heppell. A safer option IMO. Rookies all good.

MIDS:

Strong. All 4 should be average 110+ easily. Perhaps you can find a better option at 5. Maybe Clifton? Wingard?

RUCKS:

Standard. Macca should improve out of sight this year.  8)

FORWARDS:

Another great line......4 out with the bye however. Big no no if it's 4. One has to be ousted.

OVERALL:

Good team mate. Byes could hurt you, but it's pretty strong. Maybe subtract Adcock..

[Windigo]

Basumal:

BACKS:

Very strong. Maybe go with Hargrave instead of Armstrong perhaps? Hargrave tearing up! Not sold on Wilkes though. Very dodgy.

MIDS:

Loving the pick of Stanton. Really should push elite this year. Better rookie options on bench IMO. Monitor Hayes.

RUCKS:

Standard.

FORWARDS:

I'd only have one hawk player in FWD line and that's Buddy. But Lewis shapes as a good pick also. Keep him, I think he can do push 95+ this year. Solid line mate.

OVERALL:

Strong side here. Taking a few risks here and there with a few uniques. It should set you apart....In what way remains to be seen.  :P

[Windigo]

BC2010:

BACKS:

I'm on the Andy C bandwagon as well. Scores well and can smash some almighty scores on his day. Strong line. Maybe  re-think Brodie though.

MIDS:

Dominance. Gibbs thrown in there for something different. Love it. I have Hogan as well. Matura age and looks great in NAB's.

RUCKS:

Standard.

FORWARDS:

Still not sold on Porpoise. I'd rather a rookie who could potentially score the same and is better value. Lewis shapes as very decent pick up IMO. Nice FWD line.

OVERALL:

One of the best teams I've seen so far. A mix of uniques and guns. Excellent mate. Midfield is way dominant. Similar to mine, except I have my Redden.  ;)

Fantastic.  ;)

[Dutchie64]

Windigo....I have gone back to the drawing board......again!!! Thanks for your help, much appreciated.
dutchie

[nicw98]

http://img193.imageshack.us/img193/5016/screenshot20120306at618.png

[Justin Bieber]

Windy would BC2010 beat my team? haha  :P

[Windigo]

Windy would BC2010 beat my team? haha  :P

Any team can beat another team on any given week.

dan77:

BACKS:

Too many dodgy picks IMO. Shoe, Lake & Golby make me say no way! Re-think that backline. Gets some saftety in there! Hargrave?

MIDS:

Strong. I don't mind the Coniglio choice. Should tear up!

RUCKS:

Hm, I hope this doesn't become a trend. Mac-Giles is way too risky. Don't wanna get to greedy with the rucks.

FORWARDS:

Very strong line mate. Stevie will be a fairly unique selection. Good forward choices.

OVERALL:

Backs are too dodgy. I'd scrap that and try again. Maybe downgrade a premium in the FWD line? Also, really not sold on Giles & Mac combo.  :-\

[Windigo]

Jalapeno:

BACKS:

Solid backs. The two Carlton players are way underpicked in DT for really no reason other that price. Andy C beat Birch any day of the week.....Oh, you have him as well.  :P Super strong, no Goddard could back fire if he recaptures form.....

MIDS:

Strong. I like Stanton, such a damaging fantasy scorer and deserves a spot! Strong midfield mate.

RUCKS:

Good options. Jacobs should improve the most this year.

FORWARDS:

I'd rethink the FWD rookies.....Solid top 4. Really not sold on Dangerfield. It could be just another tease. Don't get sucked in mate!

OVERALL:

Very nice team indeed. A few quirky selections. But they all work. Solid team. If Danger fires...Even better! Great team, maybe the FWD rookies need more analysis.

[Windigo]

Chelskiman:

BACKS:

Nice. Very good top 4. Your gunna cop a 0 somewhere anyway! Solid back line.

MIDS:

Solid midfield here mate. Good rookie options.  ;)


RUCKS:

Finally! Someone has gone with the best premium combo IMO. Jacobs & McEvoy. Both number one rucks and both can only improve? Did I influence this selection? I remember saying something about it. But not sure.  :P

FORWARDS:

Another solid line mate. Rookies could prove a headache as IMO none of them would have very good JS at this stage. Monitor, but cash to spend on at least to Dazza or someone?

OVERALL:

Backline is BOSS. Love it. Rucks combo is ace. Great team, but your FWD rookies all at this stage are very dodgy IMO.

[Windigo]

Papps13:

BACKS:

Seems solid enough. Bit skeptical on Waters' fitness however. If he doesn't play a NAB, Then you'd be a brave man to play him from round 1 in your team.

MIDS:

Solid. Don't go Danger in mids. Get him FWD if you want him. I'd go Sloane. Barlow is way dodgy with the shins at this stage. Solid mids.

RUCKS:

Dominance! Cox should slay at great clip again this year.

OVERALL:

From what I've seen it's good team. Get Danger if you can break one of your concrete FWD's.  :P