Post Up Your Team And I'll Leave My Thoughts!

[Windigo]

Stocutz:

BACKS:

Hm, very weak with Mackie at 2. There is too many mid pricers for my liking. I like Mackie. But your back line is drastically in need of some strength.

MIDS:

Very strong. Just make sure Kav get's games. Not sold on him just yet.

RUCKS:

Good. Sandi in there gives it some more 'oomph.'

FORWARDS:

Once again, very strong. The correct balance of guns & upcoming guns. I like Shannon, very cheap for what he can deliver.

OVERALL:

Good team here mate. But that backline is very dodgy. I'd recommend getting at least Shaw or another gun in there somewhere. But great effort!  ;)

[Windigo]

Arthur Dent:

BACKS:

Yes. Someone has the best defender in the business in Scotland!  :D Good top 3. But who is MacDonald? Watch Lake, potential pick of the year he can recapture some form...

MIDS:

Good top 4. Maybe re-think Smith & Mitchell. Get in Shiel. But good line.

RUCKS:

Cox & Jamar! Hm, he is worth a punt. But that is a very interesting call there mate. Could pay off, but then again. Very risky.

FORWARDS:

Don't like Watts or Butcher. I'd find other possibilities for them with your cash in the bank. Don't know much about Crozy...But good line. Fyfe should slay this year!

OVERALL:

Quality team. A few left field options in Watts & Jamar. Huge risks with both. I'd suggest re-jigging things a bit in the FWD line. But Scotland is a dynamite scorer!

[Domination Station]

BACKS: Goddard, Shaw, Hanley, Duffield, Hargrave, Howard, Ellis (Sierakowski, Bugg)

MIDS: Ablett, Selwood, Thompson, Stanton, Ledger, McDonald (Neale, Miles)

RUCKS: Leuenberger, Giles (Stephenson, Gorringe)

FORWARDS: Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Veszpremi, Cripps (Horlin-Smith, Hampton)

400 bucks in the kitty. Very much a high risk, high reward team.
Thoughts would be great!

[Hitman3095]

Hitman3095:

BACKS:

Good top 4. Hargrave can either way. He could be a great pick, or can stink it up. Really watch him during the NAB. Don't get sucked in! Rookies are decent. Nice line.

MIDS:

Love seeing Boyd in there mate. Mitchell is injured and you should probably get rid of him. I think Stevens will struggle to get games this year because of the depth of talent in the midfield. Apart from that, it's a strong line.

RUCKS:

Strong. Rucks share the same bye however....

FORWARDS:

Good safe options. Maybe keep monitoring Zaha. Needs to show more for me to be convinced of his 100+ point scoring ability. Don't know much about this Koo guy?  :P Great line. Watch the rookies though.

OVERALL:

A very strong team mate. Just make sure on Hargrave, really is a teaser and only one good season DT wise. Be wary. But well thought out across the lines. Re_Adjust rucks for the bye though.  :)

Hmmm.... thanks heaps for the review mate! This would take ageeeeess to do everyones!
New improvements to the team, your thoughts? Cheers mate :)



Could always go...
Martin for Zaharakis ?
or
Gray for Martin and Winderlich for Porplyzia ?
Also, being a Carlton supporter shall I bring in Murphy for someone like Boyd or Selwood? Thanks again.

[Chiprock]

Any opinions would be greatly appreciated, cheers  :D

[dicey7]

Defs - Deledio ,Goddard, Grimes, Broughton, Eliis, Darley, Bugg (brown,wilkes)

Mids - Swan, Ablett, Rockliff, J Selwood, Shiel, treolar, (neale,Kerridge)

Rucks - Sandi, Luey ( giles, Stephenson)

Fwds - Buddy, Goodes, Fyfe, Martin, N.Riewoldt, pfiffer, zorko (smedts,hampton)

16,300 in Bank

[canavpies]

Def- goddard H.shaw birchall dempsey hawksley scotland ellis ( bugg hine)
Mid- ablett selwood shiels hayes mcdonald shiel ( zorko brown)
Rk - leuenberger giles ( derickx stephenson)
Fwd - franklin goodes martin brown rohan porplyzia pfeiffer ( smith hampton)

thx for the help ($363,800)

[Windigo]

Probably do a few tomorrow, or maybe on Tuesday. Got some S.A.C's to study for.  :'(

[turry17]

Baks:
Goddard, Carrazzo, Shaw, Deledio, Lake, Bugg, Morris (Smedts, Wilkes)

Mids:
Swan, Boyd, Ablett, Swallow D, Hampton, Shiel (Brown, Mitchell)

Ruks:
Luenburger, Giles (Derikx, Stephenson)

Fowards:
Johnson, Franlin, Goodes, Pavlich, Martin, Trelour, Walsh (Hall, Kerridge)

$36 000 left, Rookies will defenitly change after NAB

[Windigo]

Domination Station:


BACKS:

Bit light on with Hanley at 3. I'd really look to add another premium to the backs. Too many risks for my liking. I'd really re-think having Howard & Hargrave until a few more NAB's. Rookies good.

MIDS:

Very strong top 4. Love Stanton's ability in DT! Don't know much about Ledger?  ??? Rookies all good. Maybe re-think Ledger?

RUCKS:

Standard. I'd go for a cheaper option than Orange.

FORWARDS:

Nice top 4. I don't agree with the 3 mid pricers. Really could be a fatal mistake going with all 3. Maybe try one of them perhaps.

OVERALL:

Well made team with a few dubious picks. Namely your fwd line and you back line needs another premium in there. Shaw or Enright. Maybe Birchall. Also, Orange is wasted at 3. Downgrade. Good team, just tweak it a bit!

"Very much a high risk, high reward team." Good summary of your team.... :P

[LEV]

BACKS
Goddard, Heppell, Fisher, Hargrave, Clarke, Darley, Bugg (Smedts, Morris)

MIDS
Swan, Boyd, GAJ, Mitchell, Jelwood, Shiel (Sexton, Magnar)

RUCKS
Sandi, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)

FORWARDS
Franklin, Goodes, Pav, Robinson, Dusty, Hampton, Treloar (Cameron, Walsh)

I have weak backs i know, but make it up elsewhere.  Aim is to start double trading rookies a few weeks out from byes.  Might have to do a few sideways trades to avoid donuts.  What do you think? any advice / criticism more than welcome :) thank mate :)

[Windigo]

Hitman3095: Review #2

BACKS:

Strong top 4. All should be fairly safe options. Particularly Heppell. Will improve, but not a huge spike I wouldn't' think. Strong line. Maybe watch Hargrave..Not keen on him after just a couple T20's. He has been forgotten for a reason.

MIDS:

Excellent top 4. Boyd should be a unique gun pick in the early rounds. Wait Kyal to be elevated, then pounce on him! Great strong and even balanced line.

RUCKS:

Strong. Hamish still scored well in the game he played with Goldstein last year.

FORWARDS:

My personal favorite top 4. Pavlich in better shape than last year and will push 100+ this year playing at FF where he slays. Not keen on Porplyzia. Would rather a rookie TBH.... Dunno who the Koo guy is.... :P

OVERALL:

Very impressive team mate. I think I caught your first team post thread. I think it ws you had all the cheap rookies and shower. You've come a long way since then!  ;) Maybe watch Hargrave. Porpoise is a huge risk IMO.

I'd go Martin over Zaha. Keep Boyd great player. Keep Martin. I'd rather Winderleich to Porpoise though...

[Windigo]

ChipRock:

BACKS:

Strong. But your gunna have a headache with 3 out during round 13? Keep Scotland, best defender in the business. Greta line though!

MIDS:

Love seeing Sammy and Rocky in there. Nice unique vibe in the mids. Maybe get a better rookie than Neale to be your 6th. Great.

RUCKS:

Strong. Mummy is dominant and Hamish was a previous gun ruck!

FORWARDS:

IMO Gray is a number 5 FWD. But that's just the way I have him. Fyfe or Pav? I think it just comes down to preference. Both are great picks. Great FWD line. Get Dazza on field! Maybe watch Tommy. -1 in NAB isn't good for first impressions. But keep him until next week and assess then.

OVERALL:

Good team mate. I'm loving the unique mids. Could set you apart. I'd like another FWD gun in there somewhere. I rate Gray highly, but I don't he'll score as much for a 4th forward. But Brown_dog offsets though. Great team.  ;)

[Windigo]

Dicey7:

BACKS:

I'd look for another premium. Too much is relying on the un-reliable Brougton to score well.  :P Also, having Marty Clarke makes any back line look better IMO. I'd look to get him in somewhere.

MIDS:

Strong. Nice bit of uniqueness with the absolute gun in Rockliff. Isn't Treloar better suited to FWD's with so many options in the mids? But his good for DPP link.  ;) I wouldn't have Kerridge in mids though.

RUCKS:

Strong. Cannot fault that!  ;)

FORWARDS:

Great top 4. Bit of a risk with Roo. But he should bounce back. But not to any great heights I wouldn't think. He ain't a bad pick though. Just keep watching him. Rookies solid. Keep monitoring Smedts.

OVERALL:

Great team here. Rucks are great and it hasn't really affected the strength of your team too much. Maybe the back line is a tad understrength. Particularly if Broughton is as inconsistent as last year? Maybe Heppel instead?

[Hitman3095]

Hitman3095: Review #2

BACKS:

Strong top 4. All should be fairly safe options. Particularly Heppell. Will improve, but not a huge spike I wouldn't' think. Strong line. Maybe watch Hargrave..Not keen on him after just a couple T20's. He has been forgotten for a reason.

MIDS:

Excellent top 4. Boyd should be a unique gun pick in the early rounds. Wait Kyal to be elevated, then pounce on him! Great strong and even balanced line.

RUCKS:

Strong. Hamish still scored well in the game he played with Goldstein last year.

FORWARDS:

My personal favorite top 4. Pavlich in better shape than last year and will push 100+ this year playing at FF where he slays. Not keen on Porplyzia. Would rather a rookie TBH.... Dunno who the Koo guy is.... :P

OVERALL:

Very impressive team mate. I think I caught your first team post thread. I think it ws you had all the cheap rookies and shower. You've come a long way since then!  ;) Maybe watch Hargrave. Porpoise is a huge risk IMO.

I'd go Martin over Zaha. Keep Boyd great player. Keep Martin. I'd rather Winderleich to Porpoise though...

hahaha, yep that was me  :D
I must say though, I wouldn't have came this far without all you people!
Who do you think are contenders to replace Hargrave? Howard, Lake, Armstrong, Suban or Conca?
Thanks again for the review mate! Hope you do well in your SAC's :)