Post Up Your Team And I'll Leave My Thoughts!

[Windigo]

Disatrous:

BACKS:

Very, very strong with 5 gun defenders. Perhaps to much. Heppell>Hargrave and pocked some $$$? Great line the way it though!  ;) Dunno about Talia however.

MIDS:

I wouldn't go with Reid. Clifton looks a safer bet IMO. Great top 4. Sammy should be unique and slaying week in and week out! Nice.

RUCKS:

Standard.

FORWARDS:

Missing another gun. This is why I'd definitely downgrade a back and get some more firepower into this line.

OVERALL:

Great 3 lines mate. The FWD line is lacking though. You have dominate backs. But get in Hargrave, provides great value mate.  ;)

[Windigo]

Jackson McGuire:

BACKS:

Solid top 3 mate. Maybe keep watching Broughton. Where he plays really decides how he scores. A risk.

MIDS:

Strong. Loving the Wingard inclusion, should play most games for Port. Mitchell is injured. Oust.

RUCKS:

Good combo, should net some good points from these two.  ;)

FORWARDS:

It Shannon fires, it is dominance. Stevie J way underpicked again this year. A good option ash e can smash the weak teams for 150+.  8)

OVERALL:

Pretty good team across the board. Just monitor Byrnes could back fire if he is and out of the squad. Nicely made team mate!  ;)

[Windigo]

Silent Bob:

BACKS:

Good to see no Hunt in there this time. Haha. Good top 3. Maybe not Gilbert. I have more confidence in Duff_Man honestly.  :P A word of advice, don't go near a Collingwood rookie. Dodgy as Job security mate. Also, too many mid pricers, I'd only go two.

MIDS:

Needs another premium midfielder. I hears Shuey was in crutches? Probably only a rumor. But good rookie selections, but I;d go another premium.

RUCKS:

Smith should improve. But I'd rather another premium or down to Giles/Hamish.

FORWARDS:

Dodgy as. Nahas is a big no deal from me if you already have D-Mart. FWD line as a whole is too weak.

OVERALL:

Splash the cash in your FWD line. Downgrade a back and get another quality FWD. But a good side for a guy whose passion is NRL.  ;)

[Adamant]

DEF: Goddard, Carrazzo, Shaw, Heppell, Hargrave, Clarke, Ellis (Bugg, Darley)

MID: Boyd, Ablett, Rockliff, Jelwood, Hogan, McDonald (Magner, Gibson)

RUC: Mumford, Giles (Stephenson, Redden)

FWD: Franklin, Goodes, Pavlich, Robinson, Sidebottom, Smith, Pfieffer (Cameron, Kerridge)

99k left...

Cheers

[Windigo]

Nicw98:

BACKS:

You sure about Bower? His cheap enough, so can't complain if he slays at 70+. Worth a shot. I'd rather another gun in the backs. But it's decent enough.

MIDS:

Out Didak, he shouldn't be in the midfield and he is injure with no games to his belt. Downgrade to a rookie and upgrade your back line. Good line with Bartel in there though!  :)

RUCKS:

Good. Sandi still concerns me with his durability though.

FORWARDS:

Cheaped out too much with the FWD line as well. Too dodgy across the board.

OVERALL:

It's okay, but the backs and fwds are very risky and weak. Downgrade Didak to a rookie and upgrade. Also, maybe H-Mac to Giles and inject some more guns into your team.

[Windigo]

Brodman_18:

BACKS:

Not keen on Broughton at 3. I'd only have one of him or Heppell IMO. Too early to have Golby.

MIDS:

It's great if Hayes can get back to 100+ scoring. Wait and see on his NAB performances. Rookies are solid.

RUCKS:

Dominance!  :)

FORWARDS:

Dunno about Beams. I'd rather him as an upgrade mid year myself....Wait on G.H.S. Like the look of him from last year. COuld sneak a few games. Solid.

OVERALL:

Very solid team. A few risks, but they could pay off. I like it, maybe have another back. But having two solid rucks hinders that.

[Windigo]

Adamant:

BACKS:

Solid mate. Very well thought out! Same line as me.  :o Only I have Deledio and snuck Connors in there.

MIDS:

Again, another great line with some similar selections to myself. I've got the other half of the red-rock combo. Solid options.

RUCKS:

Exactly the same as me. So that's er great.  :P

FORWARDS:

Solid options. Pav & Goodes should g o around again and smash tons in 2012. Solid rookies.

OVERALL:

Great team mate. Solid across all lines and I'm impressed. A lot of selections are parallel to mine. I dunno if that's a good thing or not at this stage. Haha.  :P

[Adamant]

Adamant:

BACKS:

Solid mate. Very well thought out! Same line as me.  :o Only I have Deledio and snuck Connors in there.

MIDS:

Again, another great line with some similar selections to myself. I've got the other half of the red-rock combo. Solid options.

RUCKS:

Exactly the same as me. So that's er great.  :P

FORWARDS:

Solid options. Pav & Goodes should g o around again and smash tons in 2012. Solid rookies.

OVERALL:

Great team mate. Solid across all lines and I'm impressed. A lot of selections are parallel to mine. I dunno if that's a good thing or not at this stage. Haha.  :P

Haha thanks mate, I guess great minds think alike  ;)

[Chelskiman]

RUCKS:

Finally! Someone has gone with the best premium combo IMO. Jacobs & McEvoy. Both number one rucks and both can only improve? Did I influence this selection? I remember saying something about it. But not sure.  :P

Haha, I have seen you post your love for that combo, and it did get me thinking, that's for sure!  Not sure if it will be the highest scoring combo, but it should at least be a consistent one.

OVERALL:

Backline is BOSS. Love it. Rucks combo is ace. Great team, but your FWD rookies all at this stage are very dodgy IMO.

Cheers, mate.  I'll keep an eye on the rookies in the next round of the NAB and, obviously, see who is named round 1.

[jezzablue]

Brett Deledio, Brendon Goddard, Heath Shaw, Ryan Hargrave, Adam Tomlinson, Marty Clarke, Steven Morris,
Billie Smedts, Tomas Bugg,

Gary Ablett jnr, Marc Murphy, Joel Selwood, Scott Pendlebury, Lenny Hayes, James Magner,
Anthony Miles, James McDonald

Shane Mumford, Matthew Kreuzer
Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson

Nathan Fyfe, Adam Goodes, Lance Franklin, Dustin Martin, Jason Porplyzia, Dayne Zorko, Devon Smith
Adam Treloar, Sam Kerridge

Appreciate your thoughts mate.... still relatively new to this so questioning myself a bit..
This weekend will confirm my rookies (whats on the bench are in question)..
I still have $125,400 in the bank..
Cheers!!

[ldlol]

Pretty cookie cutter, but would like to know what you think :)

B: Goddard, Shaw, Birchall, Heppell, Hargrave, Clarke, Bugg (Ugle, Smedts)
M: Gaz, Pendles, Boyd, Jelwood, McDonald, Magner (Neale, Shiel)
R: Mumford, Leuenberger (Giles, Stephenson)
F: Chappy, Goodes, Martin, Sidebottom, Porplyzia, Pfeiffer, Treloar (Saad, Zorko)

[Bill Manspeaker]

Goddard, Shaw, Deledio, Broughton, M.Clarke, Mohr, Smedts   (Darley, Morris)

Swan, Ablett, Selwood, S.Thompson, Clifton, Shiel   (Hampton, Brown)

Cox, Leuenberger   (Giles, Stephensen)

Franklin, Robinson, D.Martin, Sidebottom, Tomlinson, D.Smith, Pfeiffer   (Cameron, Couch)

$141,800 left


This is my first draft, so might have to play around with it a bit, would love to hear your thoughts though.


Cheers mate  :)

[korza]

Hi Windigo,

I'm at your mercy.

B: Scotland, Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, Weller, Clarke, Morris      Smetz,Bugg

M: Pendlebury, Boyd, Ablett, Murphy, Bartel, Mcdonald,                 Shiel,Magner

R: Mumford, Giles                                                                     Rowe, Stephenson

F: Chapman, Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, D.Smith, Pfieiffer,Couch           Kerridge Dell'olio


KORZA

[nicw98]

1. Scotland, h 2. Shaw, H 3. Deledio, B 4. Heppell, D 5. Hargrave, R 6. Ellis, B 7. Spurr, L     subs Mohr, T   Wilkes, B



8. Swan, D 9. Boyd, M 10. Bartel, J 11. Didak, A 12. Palmer, R 13. Masten, C  subs     Brown, L      Gibson, S



14. Sandilands, A 15. McIntosh, H   subs      Giles, J    Stephensen, O   



16. Franklin, L 17. Martin, D 18. Giansiracusa, D 19. Knights, C 20. Darling, J 21. Pfeiffer, D 22. Couch, T   subs    Zorko,  Cameron, J

[rider]

My Team: Cash $4900

Def - God, Shaw, Birch, Ad, Conca, Hargrave, Ellis (Bugg, Darley)

Mid - Swan, Ablett, Selwood, Stants, Wingard, Magner (Gibson, Neale)

Ruc - Mummy, Minson, (Giles, Redden)

Fwd - Buddy, Goodes, Dusty, Gray, Porps, Pfief, Couch (Smith, Hall)