Skinner or Walsh

Started by cortez, February 22, 2012, 11:00:03 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who will have the bigger impact out of tbese two mature aged rookie priced players?

Tommy Walsh
Zephaniah Skinner

cortez

Please vote above. if you would like to say your reason please do not hesitate to write it below. thanks.

Dylbags

Walsh, should get more opportunities and after his International rules series last year, very hard to pass up, I doubt Skinner will get regular games and if he does he's likely to go missing a bit

ando_10

walsh will score alot more IMO i think skinner will score a few 40-50s

My Chumps

Sydney's NAB cup games Friday night should tell us a bit more about Walsh's amount of gametime, roll etc.
Pretty hard to vote until then...

TheMailman

I think that Skinner still won't be a great choice for DT this year.

He does have a tiny frame and didn't make a huge amount of the few oppurtunities thrown his way. A couple of recruits have been added to give him competition.

In the case of Walsh, the only real competition he has to face is if Morton or Jesse White can put some big games in to make Longmuire consider them.

Main reasons I choose Walsh

Usman

Quote from: My Chumps on February 22, 2012, 05:37:20 PM
Sydney's NAB cup games Friday night should tell us a bit more about Walsh's amount of gametime, roll etc.
Pretty hard to vote until then...

My thoughts exactly Walsh was great in the internationals, but will it translate? lets see. he plays an unfavourable position for fantasy land.