Seems illogical

[n.r.i.]

I don't get why people are going with mcintosh, surely having Goldstein in the same side will hinder his scores a fair bit. Is there something I have missed?

[Crows84]

yeah been a thought i  have had as well, i would have thought gong with a ruck who is the one el primo would be the go, like burger, jacobs mummy etc, no one else to really do the work

[Ziplock]

how is it illogical? He's an 80+ proven scorer, who's priced at what, an average of 50? he's a perfectly logical mid pricer choice for a bargain ruck theory.

[Crows84]

absolutely his a proven scorer, but, that was before goldy stepped up. No doubt its been discussed on several threads but in my mind the unknown is between hmac and goldy if north will play them both at once ( ruck then rest fwd) or rotate  or something else. So i think hmac will still score fairly and rise in price, but i cant say i feel safe with him as a starting ruck scoring 100ppg on average this season. Id happily be proved wrong but I already have enough other risky players in my side to warrant another mid pricer

[Jukes]

McIntosh has been discussed on too many threads!!! Getting sick of hearing about him, just look at the deck of dream team article and be done with it!

[nostradamus]

have a loook at some of the previous threads on the topic of Hmac, am sure you'll find all the information and opinions ur loooking for

[n4cr123]

Priced at an ave of 50, will push close to an 80 ave.... You do the math....

[Kuruki]

Cox and NicNat both had there best ever seasons last year. Why cant Hmac and Goldy do the same???

[Torress]

if its DT i'd go for Hmac - SC probably not.