Boyd vs. Murphy

Started by Just Clancy, February 21, 2012, 03:37:45 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which one?

Boyd
19 (79.2%)
Murphy
5 (20.8%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Just Clancy

Don't know why no one is picking Boyd this year? It's almost like he's a unique.

hardnut

he's in my team at the mo' but I think there will be a rush on him during the NAB. Bullies played a short kicking game the other night and racked DT points with Boyd the star (though typically not very damaging). Murphy is a gun with upside so consider having  both?

MGK1

Plenty of people will jump on Boyd after that NAB Cup hitout.
Boyd for me.

mezzoculo

Structure means that I can't fit Murph but Boyd is still in the mix (either him or Jelwood ATM).

Just Clancy

Quote from: hardnut on February 21, 2012, 03:39:11 PM
he's in my team at the mo' but I think there will be a rush on him during the NAB. Bullies played a short kicking game the other night and racked DT points with Boyd the star (though typically not very damaging). Murphy is a gun with upside so consider having  both?
Already have Swan, Ablett and Selwood in mids so can only have 1.

PowerBug

Quote from: Just Clancy on February 21, 2012, 03:37:45 PM
Don't know why no one is picking Boyd this year? It's almost like he's a unique.
Gotta have Boyd mate. Not sure why he'd be a unique, he was the third highest scoring mid last year, in case people forgot. ;)

Flame

He somehow slips under the radar! A genuine DT gun though! Hard th go past him!

Colliwobblers

boyd for dt murphy for sc ? boyd got my vote anyway but you wouldnt be unhappy either way

Kuruki

Funny how one nab game against weakened opposition can put Boyd back to the top of everyone's thinking.
Plenty of people will say they had Boyd locked from day one, but all the teams posted in the rate my team section said otherwise. Boyd was well and truely written off, hardly anyone had him in. i wonder who will be flavor of the week after this weekend. If Rocky and Murphy fire im sure Boyd will drop back to almost unique again.

PowerBug

who you get may depend on your other premo mids. I know my other two are on other weeks so Boyd beats Murphy.

Quote from: Kuruki on February 21, 2012, 06:25:34 PM
Funny how one nab game against weakened opposition can put Boyd back to the top of everyone's thinking.
Plenty of people will say they had Boyd locked from day one, but all the teams posted in the rate my team section said otherwise. Boyd was well and truely written off, hardly anyone had him in. i wonder who will be flavor of the week after this weekend. If Rocky and Murphy fire im sure Boyd will drop back to almost unique again.
I did have Boyd originally. :P

Just Clancy

Quote from: Kuruki on February 21, 2012, 06:25:34 PM
Funny how one nab game against weakened opposition can put Boyd back to the top of everyone's thinking.
Plenty of people will say they had Boyd locked from day one, but all the teams posted in the rate my team section said otherwise. Boyd was well and truely written off, hardly anyone had him in. i wonder who will be flavor of the week after this weekend. If Rocky and Murphy fire im sure Boyd will drop back to almost unique again.
haha so true.

Bruce McAvaney

Murphy will explode with Gibbs in the middle helping him out and taking some heat

Capper

Boyd for me, lock and load at the start

Holz

Quote from: Bruce McAvaney on February 21, 2012, 07:14:08 PM
Murphy will explode with Gibbs in the middle helping him out and taking some heat

or gibbs could explode, i think he will be playing on the HF flank with stints in the midfield.

Windigo

Boyd has been a very unique pick for many years. Except last year.

Not very surprising to say the least.