please rate my team

[brodie94]

BACKS- b.goddard, b.delideo, s.fisher, d.heppell, j.grimes, b.ellis, b. smedits BENCH- b.wilikies, p.wright

MIDS- g.abblet, d.swan, m.boyd, s.mitchell, m.barlow, s.congilo  BENCH- d.shiel, d.butcher

RUCKS- z.smith, o.stevphson BENCH j.giles, j.hall

FORWARDS- buddy, a.goodes, d.martin, j.brown, j.porplesia, d.zorko, t.walsh BENCH- a.treloar , a.saad

[quinny88]

Backline- 3 best players all share the bye in rd 13
Mids- Very strong, but would cosider downgrading barlow to bring in a stronger ruckman
Rucks- Relying to much on young players to score consistantly
Forwrd- Good mix but perhaps a little risky having both brown and porpas

7.5/10

[The Supercoach]

Backline- 3 best players all share the bye in rd 13
Mids- Very strong, but would cosider downgrading barlow to bring in a stronger ruckman
Rucks- Relying to much on young players to score consistantly
Forwrd- Good mix but perhaps a little risky having both brown and porpas

7.5/10

Yea i would defiantly downgrade barlow and upgrade zac smith,besides that looks pretty good, and also porps is too risky imo and im gonna steer clear unless he shows something special in the nab cup.

[Ringo]

Not sure how much cash you have left.

Def: 3 sharing bye - maybe consider Fisher to Shaw or other similar priced player with Round 11 or Round 12 bye.
Mids: very Strong'
Rucks: Mid priced ruck with 3 rookies very risky imo. Although there is plenty of upsied to Zac smith you are relying on him to consistently return good scores as well as rookies. Look at bringing in a prem. Ruck Whether you upgrade Smith or just downgrade elsewhere to Bring in the prem is up to your team structure.
Forwards: Porps is a risk especially with now not being named for 1st round of NAB cup. Just personal with Martin's early tough draw not comfortable with him at D3.

Agree with 7.5/10 rating mainly because of risk with Ruck Structure.

[cpt.ha]

probably the showertest team ive seen so far