can you rate and suggest improvements on my dreamteam

heza · February 21, 2012, 12:05:29 AM

hi i would like suggestions and rates out of 10 on my dreamteam any advice would be helpfull

back: h. scotland, b. goddard, a. carrazzo, b. deledio, m. buntine, m. clarke, s. docherty (reserves) b. ellis, L. spurr

mid: d. swan, s. pendlebury, m. boyd, g. abblet, s. coniglio, d. tyson (reserves) s. clifton, j. mcdonald

ruck: m. leuenberger, j, giles (reserves) t. derickx, o. stephensen

forwards: L. franklin, n.fyfe, m. pavlich, d. giansiracusa, g. rohan, n. haynes, d. smith (reserves) j. paine, t. dickson

m-ry · February 21, 2012, 06:34:28 PM

Quote from: heza on February 21, 2012, 12:05:29 AM
hi i would like suggestions and rates out of 10 on my dreamteam any advice would be helpfull

back: h. scotland, b. goddard, a. carrazzo, b. deledio, m. buntine, m. clarke, s. docherty (reserves) b. ellis, L. spurr
not sure on carrazzo and scotland only one. too much money spent on buntine and clarke at there prices together

mid: d. swan, s. pendlebury, m. boyd, g. abblet, s. coniglio, d. tyson (reserves) s. clifton, j. mcdonald
4 premo are 2 thumbs up, im not keen on the 4 GWS players in the mids 3 max I'm going with but then they do have r13 bye so no problem trading out beforehand

ruck: m. leuenberger, j, giles (reserves) t. derickx, o. stephensen
i don't like but a lot are having 1 premo and 3 rooks but not for me but if the money saved is not been used well there no point

forwards: L. franklin, n.fyfe, m. pavlich, d. giansiracusa, g. rohan, n. haynes, d. smith (reserves) j. paine, t. dickson
not sure if starting fife is good with the op he had but did play well the other night. No martins !!!! and there are better players then gian and rohan at there prices. rohan maybe but gian no

Grannyboy · February 22, 2012, 08:16:58 AM

Scotland, Goddard, Carrots n Lids all rnd 13 byes might wanna watch that. I like Gia as a smoky, he went off the start of last season before dropping right off, dunno quite what you expect out of Rohan, for me, not much. Haynes, Coniglio and Tyson are pricey rooks when there so many unproven guys out there to choose from. I really like the Swanny Pendels move, not too many out there with both and you know what you're going to get from them...big scores!

yorgis · February 22, 2012, 05:10:44 PM

nuthin' wrong with gia, he averaged pretty much the same as zaha, martin, lecras, sidey, harvey, roo !!! having swan and

pendles missing rnd 12, i'm guessing your not thinking byes ?? i'm not keen on rohan and the 3 rookie ruck set up, and the

rooks will sort themselves out

heza · February 22, 2012, 08:19:46 PM

any ideas on players to swap with clarke and or buntine?
which gws players should i take out of the mid n swap with?
and same with fowards?

heza · February 22, 2012, 08:33:20 PM

with the forwards who to take n put in?

heza · February 22, 2012, 08:43:18 PM

and do i take out carazzo or scotland

Zombie2.5 · February 23, 2012, 08:06:39 PM

Quote from: heza on February 22, 2012, 08:19:46 PM
any ideas on players to swap with clarke and or buntine?
which gws players should i take out of the mid n swap with?
and same with fowards?

yeah buntines kinda expensive and pretty sure hes injured, u can keep clarke. I think m-ry meant buntine + clark = too much
i dont like your forward rookies and rohan
billie smedts looks good for fwd/def
coniglio and tyson too expensive, have a look at kavanagh(m), zorko(m/f)*, horsely(m), pffeifer(m/f)
and also look at the nab cup like weedon, neale
*zorko mite be injured but i think he'll be fine for rnd 1

Quote from: heza on February 22, 2012, 08:43:18 PM
and do i take out carazzo or scotland

i reckon scotlands getting old but still could be good pick, carrazzo would be a nice unique to have
and do i take out carazzo or scotland
hope im helping

Grannyboy · February 24, 2012, 09:51:24 AM

Quote from: heza on February 22, 2012, 08:43:18 PM
and do i take out carazzo or scotland

Meh, flip a coin.

Grannyboy · February 24, 2012, 10:06:43 AM

Quote from: heza on February 22, 2012, 08:33:20 PM
with the forwards who to take n put in?

Out: Rohan, Haynes. In: Browndog ($?), a cheaper gws rookie or maybe someone like Gumby if you back him to get his spot back now Crameri has arrived, Dick since the frenchman went down with an acl he could play a part over there. Smedts could get a bit of early action with 4 big retirements at catland...
Docherty is still injured I think so watch that and again Buntine is pricey for an untested rookie. Maybe look for some bargains in the backline to help your cap.

heza · March 24, 2012, 03:42:04 PM

ive changed my side a lot and can i get some opinons on this side

DEF: h.shaw, m.suckling, c.yarren, b.lake, c.dempssy, b.ellis, t.bugg, (reserves) a.browne, w.sierakowski

MID: G.abblett, m.boyd, s.pendlebury, d.swan, s.coniglio, d.shiel (reserves) c.wingard, c.smith

RUCKS: d.cox, d.hale, j.giles, o.stevenson

FWD: p.champman, l.franklin, n.fyfe, d.martin, s.byrnes, a.siposs, d.smith (reserves) d.zorko, a.treloar