PLEASE RATE MY SIDE :)

[quinny88]

 Just want to know what you guys think of my side.. Please rate out of 10 and make suggestions for improvement :)

DEF: B.Goddard, B.Deledio, H.Shaw, G.Johncock, B.Lake, M.Clarke, B.Ellis (S.Morris, L.brown)

MID: G.Ablett, M.Boyd, S.Mitchell, J.Watson, J.Mcdonald, D.Zorko (D.Shiel, L.Neale)

RUC: A.Sandilands, H.Mcintosh (J.Giles, O.Stephensen )

FWD: L.Franklin, P.Chapman, D.Martin, N.Riewoldt, J.Porplyzia, G.Weedon, B.Smedts (R.Cooyou, A.Treloar)

$33,500 remaining
Rookies to be determined throught the Nab cup. Also waiting to see the form of Lake and Porplyzia during the nab cup

[j959]

Just want to know what you guys think of my side.. Please rate out of 10 and make suggestions for improvement :)

DEF: B.Goddard, B.Deledio, H.Shaw, G.Johncock, B.Lake, M.Clarke, B.Ellis (S.Morris, L.brown)

MID: G.Ablett, M.Boyd, S.Mitchell, J.Watson, J.Mcdonald, D.Zorko (D.Shiel, L.Neale)

RUC: A.Sandilands, H.Mcintosh (J.Giles, O.Stephensen )

FWD: L.Franklin, P.Chapman, D.Martin, N.Riewoldt, J.Porplyzia, G.Weedon, B.Smedts (R.Cooyou, A.Treloar)

$33,500 remaining
Rookies to be determined throught the Nab cup. Also waiting to see the form of Lake and Porplyzia during the nab cup

quinny, i'm pretty harsh ...

-0.5 for risk in Johncock/Lake (scaled down from 1 - assuming you're taking a calculated risk with those two)
-0.5 risk in Watson (will he play the whole season) and factoring a little Zorko (will he be fully fit rd1?)
-0.5 risk in Chappy (age/hammys), NRoo (not sure if he'll get back to his best), Weedon (rookie list??)

gives you 8.5 - not too shabby, good luck!

[MC]

What about Hmac and Porpoise? Surely -0.5 for those as well!

[quinny88]

thanks j959.. i deffinetly agree with your risk assesments but i thought my main risks were lake and porplyzia. all rookies are only based on what ive heard and based on rd 1 nab cup signs. who would you suggest in place of johncock and watson? thanks