Cheap defenders....

Started by n4cr123, February 20, 2012, 03:41:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who has looked the best so far/most potential

Hargrave
11 (36.7%)
Howard
4 (13.3%)
Conca
9 (30%)
Lake (no show yet)
2 (6.7%)
Davis
3 (10%)
Other
1 (3.3%)

Total Members Voted: 3

n4cr123


picker_man

i wont b tacking any but hargrave could b a good pick he might b the one to roam around the doggies backline, conce will prolly get suspended 4 1st few games..... others im not a fan off

nostradamus

Out of the ones that uv mention hargrave is the only one that l might consider. But will have to see some more of him before l decide, especially in tandem with Lake, as his role may change when playing with him. Anyway its ealry days yet, hopefully Lake plays soon and makes things a bit easier to decide

picker_man

when the swannies play watch out 4 armstrong could b another option

sid3bysid3

Don't consider hargrave. Has had one good season and not even premier scores. Howard has a lot more potential and could be used to reload with that left boot. If these duties are shared between him, hargrave and gilbee then get a rook and use the extra cash to boost other spots

Capper

Quote from: picker_man on February 20, 2012, 03:57:10 PM
when the swannies play watch out 4 armstrong could b another option

do you think he is on the best 22?? i dont

Jukes

Out of those I'd go Hargarve but I'd rather get a rookie, plenty of great back rookie choices this season.

picker_man

Quote from: tabs on February 20, 2012, 04:55:46 PM
Quote from: picker_man on February 20, 2012, 03:57:10 PM
when the swannies play watch out 4 armstrong could b another option

do you think he is on the best 22?? i dont
he would fit into kenelly's position nicely and i think he will be in there best 22 but its just another name ive put into the mix to watch i wont be taking him haha

Windigo

Don't be influenced too much by a couple of short NAB games.

Monitor Hargrave though!

SydneyRox

Conca for me. He will now play rnd 1 - unless they contest, and i cant see why they would.

elephants

Conca only.
If he gets off he should be in.
If he gets 1 week he is locked.
Anymore no way.