Rate my team (picture) - feedback appreciated

billnats · February 19, 2012, 03:05:13 AM

Made some changes, but not sure if they were for the better. I have $15k to muck around with the bench players or change a Swallow/Selwood to a Priddis/Mitchell.

Feedback appreciated

MC · February 19, 2012, 01:00:03 PM

Def - Very solid, I like it
Mids - Strong, 1 more premium than mine.
Ruck - I love the Luenberger pick, hopefully Hmac steps it up this year for you!
Fwd - I'd swap Johnson to Goodes, but otherwise good. (Rowe as a rookie I don't like - KPP not guaranteed games)

9/10 if Porpoise dominates the NAB :)

SonsOfZeus · February 19, 2012, 01:51:25 PM

def- not bad, stay clear of grimes
mids-nice picks but as MC i have 1 less prem
rucks-good unique picks will probs have to waste trades on hmac though
fwds-dont like. stevie j is overatted take away his game against GC and meLB and his average wouldnt be so good. rioli is to injury prone for my liking. sidebottom is overpriced.

bit of work in fwds but not as bad start 6.5/10

billnats · February 19, 2012, 06:05:02 PM

Thanks guys,
Interesting to see the difference in thoughts.

I do agree with Johnson and I have brought in Goodes.
I reckon Steele is going to have his real break out year so sticking by him and rioli is utter class.

Who can I bring in instead of Rowe?

MC · February 19, 2012, 08:11:37 PM

Pfeiffer? He should be promoted imo.

billnats · February 19, 2012, 09:13:03 PM

7 grand short on him and Saad!

Looking at a 113k forward unfortunately

Cookie Monster · February 19, 2012, 09:18:36 PM

Quote from: SonsOfZeus on February 19, 2012, 01:51:25 PM
def- not bad, stay clear of grimes
mids-nice picks but as MC i have 1 less prem
rucks-good unique picks will probs have to waste trades on hmac though
fwds-dont like. stevie j is overatted take away his game against GC and meLB and his average wouldnt be so good. rioli is to injury prone for my liking. sidebottom is overpriced.

bit of work in fwds but not as bad start 6.5/10

Steve Johnson overatted?

please..

minus those games he still averaged 90, plus, he will play those games, you can't say, he averaged over 100 because of his 2 games, they had a good majority, but he plays those games.