NAB Cup Player Discussion

[StuL]

Mitchell impressive as per usual.

In fact the hawks in general are very impressive

I guess you posted this before they lost to the Tiges!! I thought the squawks would be getting excited. haha. Suffer. Lost to Richmond. Awesome.

[elephants]

When will we know about Conca's suspension?

[StuL]

I should have gone to my dads so I could watch the games! So hard trying to work out how they are actually playing by judging off DT points. Has Swallow been playing well?

He was alright but pretty much lived up to his current ranking. Doesn't fit into my philosophy of 'top-shelf' and kids only in the mids.

[Colliwobblers]

When will we know about Conca's suspension?

I have no idea should hear more about it today on afl site or maybe tonight game broadcasts. After the games the different commentators talked it down like he was in the clear, but the fact is he stopped looked at the guy then held his ground so it can be said the contact was deliberate thats the problem, even tho the guy ran into him conca held his ground and he can argue that but he could have kept going not stopped and held his ground, i reckon its a soft incident but they are taking a hard line on that and im betting 2 weeks he will be made an example of.

[Colliwobblers]

When will we know about Conca's suspension?

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/129123/default.aspx

[Windigo]

Did Swallow have much game time, in both games?

7 touches in the first half?

Watch the Duff Sunday! Cross fingers for a loose man in defense or running half back role....Lyon better not play funny buggers and swing him deep like he did in the intra club game.

[matt1985]

Did Swallow have much game time, in both games?

7 touches in the first half?

Watch the Duff Sunday! Cross fingers for a loose man in defense or running half back role....Lyon better not play funny buggers and swing him deep like he did in the intra club game.

If he does play deep, I think my swap of Swallow and Duff, will be going back to Murphy, Hargrave. Or possibly Conca if not suspended for too long.

[Windigo]

I'll be keeping Swallow throughout.

All eyes will be on Duff_Man.  ;)

[Colliwobblers]

im watching duffield, swallow is a gun, really hard to rate premiums in nab cup they dont risk them, they rest them, hard to tell no worries about swallows ability or motivation as captain.

I hope conca tries to fight it and gets 4 or 5 so i have a rookie cow fattened up that i ca nsideways trade to conca round 6 or 7 when he is on his bubble.

barlow is what i needed to see in nab cup and looks like we arent gonna see him now, looking at cotchin for his spot now

[matt1985]

I'll be keeping Swallow throughout.

All eyes will be on Duff_Man.  ;)

I rate Swallow and started him last year. I know it was only the first NAB round and guess I can't really judge him from a couple half games. But i'm heading over seas 1st March for a month and have to try settle on my team before leaving. Won't have a chance to see the rest of the NAB and decide on the last night of lock out :(

[Windigo]

im watching duffield, swallow is a gun, really hard to rate premiums in nab cup they dont risk them, they rest them, hard to tell no worries about swallows ability or motivation as captain.

I hope conca tries to fight it and gets 4 or 5 so i have a rookie cow fattened up that i ca nsideways trade to conca round 6 or 7 when he is on his bubble.

barlow is what i needed to see in nab cup and looks like we arent gonna see him now, looking at cotchin for his spot now

Yeah mate. That's spot on.

We all knew Mithcell & Franklin were guns so them smashing it was really no surprise. The rookie players/what roles coaches choose for certain players is what we look for most in NAB games.

I starte Swallow last year as well.  ;)

[Jalapeno]

What were peoples thoughts on jack ziebell?

[Colliwobblers]

i want swallow in my SC side i have rocky becasue i have a man crush on him but i think for SC redden and swallow are the next big things, and priddis but i have him already. just pulling the trigger on swallow, i got to work up to it being a DT'er for longer i wouldn't consider him for that (yet) but i think in SC he demands consideration.

Eyeball (zieball) didnt screem pick me in the games last night but again he didnt do anything wrong either just eased into the game i feel and didnt show much, but you can't see that in a negative way it's just how it played out, big wraps on the guy and if he wasnt suspended first up you can bet he would be in a LOT of sides, he tore it up much late last season he got noticed by people who didn't even notice the side he was playing in.

norths one of those sides thats on the brink of clicking into the next gear, must be frustrating being a supporter because they are so close to lifting and have some great personel now to get it done, but might take another year yet...

[JBs-Hawks]

Cant really take too much out of these half games in regards to mid pricers/potential prems, better off waiting for the full games.

[Windigo]

Cant really take too much out of these half games in regards to mid pricers/potential prems, better off waiting for the full games.

Exactly.  :)