rate my supercoach

Started by themightyhawks, February 17, 2012, 06:17:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

themightyhawks

rate my team please - post nab cup

$194,000 left over atm


Ringo

Solid pretty standard team. 8/10

Maybe look at another prem in def if Clarke does not come up in NAB cup with extra cash.

themightyhawks

#2
Quote from: Ringo on February 17, 2012, 06:44:00 PM
Solid pretty standard team. 8/10

Maybe look at another prem in def if Clarke does not come up in NAB cup with extra cash.



you say 8/10 how would i get closer to 10/10

i thourght players like heppell, leuenburger and sidebottom would be a bit unique

Ringo

Berger, Heppell and Sidebottom while appearing unique are in quite a few teams that i have seen.

My reason for the 8 rating are
McIntosh in ruck do not think he will score well and there have been a number of threads on this. Would have been 8.5 if another prem ruck my opinion though,
Secondly being conservative with ratings until permanent rookies are chosen following NAB cup as any rating on team with rookies at the moment are purely subjective.

themightyhawks

Quote from: Ringo on February 17, 2012, 07:14:42 PM
Berger, Heppell and Sidebottom while appearing unique are in quite a few teams that i have seen.

My reason for the 8 rating are
McIntosh in ruck do not think he will score well and there have been a number of threads on this. Would have been 8.5 if another prem ruck my opinion though,
Secondly being conservative with ratings until permanent rookies are chosen following NAB cup as any rating on team with rookies at the moment are purely subjective.

okay so maby use my money to get sandi or somthing? thanks for your time

themightyhawks

Quote from: themightyhawks on February 17, 2012, 07:17:24 PM
Quote from: Ringo on February 17, 2012, 07:14:42 PM
Berger, Heppell and Sidebottom while appearing unique are in quite a few teams that i have seen.

My reason for the 8 rating are
McIntosh in ruck do not think he will score well and there have been a number of threads on this. Would have been 8.5 if another prem ruck my opinion though,
Secondly being conservative with ratings until permanent rookies are chosen following NAB cup as any rating on team with rookies at the moment are purely subjective.

okay so maby use my money to get sandi or somthing? thanks for your time


dustin managed to get some pretty decent scores against top teams last year even in loses (coll: 109, 126 loss against north, loss to west coast 97, 117 loss to sydney, loss to bulldogs 97, 96 loss to hawthorn) and with mcintosh i see him scoring a rising atleast a little bit, get a second ruck premium later on