Judd or Shiels?

[Birryfy]

Judd has that niggle with his shoulder, but I trust him to perform better then Shiels if he's fit, who should I pick?

[mezzoculo]

Or Montagna? Same price range ($480k), same bye (Rnd 13) and biggest upside, IMO.

[Windigo]

Judd is the ultimate professional. Consistent.

Shiels is an up and coming star. So young. More upside, but more of a risk IMO.

[Birryfy]

Judd is the ultimate professional. Consistent.

Shiels is an up and coming star. So young. More upside, but more of a risk IMO.

I think Ill watch both of them through the NAB Cup, if Judd is fit he's definitely in.

[Adamant]

Shiels IMO younger, more upside and should improve.

[Dudge]

Judd is the ultimate professional. Consistent.

Shiels is an up and coming star. So young. More upside, but more of a risk IMO.

Better the Devil u know. But in saying that i have neither

[Jukes]

Barlow? Save 60k and he'll surely average more then Judd and probably more then Shiel.

[Justin Bieber]

What about Watson? Similar price area.

[Bruce McAvaney]

judd. shiels could go backwards and hasnt proven himself over many years

[JBs-Hawks]

So many better options

[elephants]

Montagna. Judd not a DTer.

[Master Q]

Judd not a Dt'er.

[owenbond007]

judds a waste of cash no good at dt if anyone picks him i doubt they really wont have much success.

[Ziplock]

Judd's good at dreamteam, but I doubt will ever be classified elite. Of those two I would be looking at shiels... however, would much prefer andy swallow :P

[stew42]

Yeah, neither. Judd, whilst consistent, won't be an elite DTer, and Shiels has just come out of a breakout year, so his consistency might be in doubt.