honesty is the best policy

[ben_ess94]

fellow super coaches, 

give me honest opinions appreciated and any other suggestions Particualr defence!

DEF
Goddard, Deledio, Broughten, Hurn, Nicholson, Clarke, Ellis, (Blee, Mohr) *** struggling with the 3rd and 4th def

MIDS
Ablett, Pendlebury, Murphy, Morabito, Zorko, Shiel, (l brown, Lee) **have heard zorko/sheil both under injury clouds!

Rucks
Cox, Mcintosh, (stephenson, giles) **hows mcintosh?

FWDS
Buddy, Martin, Beams, Fyfe, BRown, Treoloer, Smidts, (pfferifer, kerridge)

thanks lads <3

P.S always happy to comment on others if you link me yours! and reply on mine

[fever]

not bad ben. to answer your questions broughton is fine for D3 though i'd keep an eye on how lyon plays him through the nab cup. hurn underperformed last year. i dont know much about nicholson but for a low end mid pricer i'd want JS and some midfiled time. do you know something we dont about him? lake is a similar price and word is his head is better under mccartney.

not sure re zorko and shiels, but imo pendles is too highly priced and looks to be a great target for after the byes when he's likely shed some value. i'd suggest swan or selwood to replace. extra cash saved could upgrade hurn to shaw/birchall/fisher/suckling/enright

rucks and fwds look good.

[WillDel]

Broughton might have a role change but with Lyon he could possibly take a shutdown role.

Morabito - watch in NAB
Ide drop pendles to a swan or selwood and upgrade morabito to a prem

McIntosh is a balssy choice, sub rule meant alot of teams went for one ruck playing majority of game with a pinch hit by tall fwd or back. North deciding they need Mcintosh make me nervous about rotation. Though they could use mcintosh at FF and have petrie at CHF. A bit to traditional for me to think they will use it.

Martin has a tough draw. Fyfe hasnt had much of a preseason though from all reports he is still slaying it in the praccie games.

Regarding rooks just watch NAB cup and be prepared to change as teams announce round one teams.

7/10 - Have a look at mine if you could. http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,48385.0.html

[ben_ess94]

@fever thanks for that. Nicholson is my smokey, been tearing up pre-season winning all time trials and the works, from what i have seen at melb going for a younger approach (again but i reckon he will have chance to break into lineup however will always depend on the lineup rd1) Hurn i have no idea struggling in that D4 slot majorly!

@ Willdell Morabito deffs watching and same as broughten i like the idea of dropping a pendles now i think about it more can't maintain that price for at least for 5 rds anyways! Instead of martin who else? I was looking at Sylvia? and rucks il have a play and see what i can come up with! 

[SonsOfZeus]

@fever thanks for that. Nicholson is my smokey, been tearing up pre-season winning all time trials and the works, from what i have seen at melb going for a younger approach (again but i reckon he will have chance to break into lineup however will always depend on the lineup rd1) Hurn i have no idea struggling in that D4 slot majorly!

@ Willdell Morabito deffs watching and same as broughten i like the idea of dropping a pendles now i think about it more can't maintain that price for at least for 5 rds anyways! Instead of martin who else? I was looking at Sylvia? and rucks il have a play and see what i can come up with!

winning time trials means nothing IMO look at saints(my team) we have brett peake, not bad but nothing special. stick with what fever said and downgrade pendles and nicholson upgrade hurn to a prem

[ben_ess94]

Had a few changes what yal think!


DEF
Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Hurn, Docherty, Clarke, Morris, (Blee, Mohr) *** struggling with the 3rd and 4th def

MIDS
Ablett, Swanny, Murphy, Morabito, Zorko, Shiel, (l brown, Lee) **have heard zorko/sheil both under injury clouds!

Rucks
Cox, Kruezer, (stephenson, giles)

FWDS
Buddy, Goodes, Beams, Fyfe, BRown, Treoloer, Hampton, (pfferifer, kerridge)


docherty? or smedts?