rate my team guys!

[joshh]

Backs: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Broughton, Clarke, Mohr, Smedts (Morris, Blee)

Mids: Ablett, Swan, Murphy, Selwood, Zorko, Shiel (Mcdonald, Mitchell)

Rucks: Mumford, Giles (Witts, Stephensons)

Forwards: franklin, Rioli, Martin, N. Riewoldt, J.Brown, Saad, Dick (Wilson, Ferguson)

[ben_020285]

I really like this team. My biggest issue is your rucks.

BACKS: Great. Wouldn't change a thing.

MIDS: Perfect but to bring in a prem ruckman you will need to downgrade one of Swan or Selwood to Barlow.

RUCKS: I would upgrade Witts to McEvoy and bench Giles.

FWDS: Too many prem players here from the round 13 bye (Franklin, Rioli, Martin, N Riewoldt). This will cause you multiple donuts during round 13. Of those players, I think you need to downgrade N Roo to a rookie to make way for your prem ruck. Hampton from GWS is a good option. Also Dick won't be right for round 1 after his knee reco so Walsh from Sydney is a good rookie pick here.

8/10

[mark621]

Seen a few people blast nroo out.. am I missing something?as for team  I would probably shuffle up a fwd to rookie to get the ruck sorted. Or at least have you plan to upgrade the ruck very early on..

My thoughts. Other than that 8/10am is good

[tor01doc]

A bit greedy in the guts I reckon.

Seems you'll miss on a good mid rookie and the cash.

Agree rucks a bit off - strong faith in 2 premium / 2 rookie set up.

Also brave to admit that up front you have a Saad  :-[ Dick  ::).

[PICCOLLO]

3rd bye will mess up your fwds.
Ull lose mummy and stephenson in your rucks at same time so you'll need witts playing.