please rate 1st draft (2nd draft now)

[sticks]

By sticks4 at 2012-02-14

might have too many GWS, any thoughts

[ben_020285]

Hey mate. You have a nice team there but a few too many mid pricers in your team for my liking. I think a few changes are required.

BACKS: I would change M Johnson and Hansen into 2 rookie priced players. Bugg from GWS and Steven Morris are two good picks.

MIDS: I would swap D Swallow for Barlow here. Both priced around the same but surely Barlow will average 10 or more points this season. I would trade out Golds for L Brown from Adelaide as it looks like he will play round 1 and so you have the dpp link with your backs and mids still.

RUCKS: Just swap Pattison for Stephenson from Geelong.

FWDS: You will have enough cash leftover to upgrade Winderlich to a player of your choice. Goodes would be my pick with his easy draw for the first half of the season.

Then you should still have a bit of cash leftover and room for one more bargain upgrade somewhere. Maybe J Brown in your fwds if you can afford it?

8/10 at the moment

[sticks]

By sticks4 at 2012-02-15

have done some changes and took onboard what ben said too

BACKS: OUT, M johnson, L hansen, T mohr, b wilkes
            IN C tarrent, S morris, T bugg, J allen

MIDS:  OUT, D swallow, D shiel, T golds
          IN, M barlow, L brown, T mitchell

RUCKS: OUT, A pattioson (fwd) (lost dpp here)
           IN, O stephensen

FWDS: OUT, J winderlich, T couch
           IN, A goodes, B smedts

this also reduced 2 GWS players from my original team
please tell me your thoughts and rate thanks

[sticks]

thining about trying to fit Pav in or shell i wait?
at this stage i dont know if i should do any chages or leave it at that
any comment would be good

[fever]

looks really good.

cant see any way you'd fit pav without either swapping a fwd prem or downgrading one of your rucks to a rookie then upping a fwd rookie.

i would swap out tarrant. he's a good player but not a good SC scorer. lake or phil davis are good options for a straight swap.

don't love bower either, take marty clarke from the pies for a similar price