Zaha or Martin?

[StuL]

This is a huge q that should affect most coaches! You have to
Pick one I reckon. Which one?

[Grannyboy]

Zahahahahahaha, you're not serious are you? I don't put rookies in off the back of one ok season, why would I go Zaha? He's neither gun nor rookie, I can't see any point having him.

[JamSainter]

Zahahahahahaha, you're not serious are you? I don't put rookies in off the back of one ok season, why would I go Zaha? He's neither gun nor rookie, I can't see any point having him.

You could say the same about Martin you know...

[Torress]

dusty has the round 13 bye and i already have 2 players who will be in my side come round 12 bye so atm zaha can't get a look in.

zaha is an interesting one - the knee tendintitis he struggled with last season but played with isn't what you want to know for a starting 'prem'. its all so reliant for him to get the opportunity in the middle, i think it might be more melkshem,howlett, colyer, lonergan, stants, hocking, watson all getting in the guts before he does as well. @490k he has quite a bit of risk associated with him, as if he were to just play mostly forward it would be a dud pick.

[Torress]

and atleast we know dusty will be in the guts! and cotch (probably will be) but might not be ready round 1. and lids should help dusty's scoring this season if playing in the middle as well.

[Bruce McAvaney]

more mid time for lids and tuck means martin plays forward more. zaha

[Windigo]

Not keen on Zaha as of yet.

Martin for me.  :)

[StuL]

I've seen more of Martin so was leaning that way but maybe there was some fans of zaha who know better, that was my thinking

[milisha]

With Richmond's draw, I'd have to go Zaha at this stage.

[Justin Bieber]

I've got Martin at the moment, but I don't see the huge hype of him? Get Mitch Robinson if you can.

[D.Zanetti]

Martin was locked in as one of my 1st 4 players picked, but now as we approach the dreaded & anticipated lockout, I'm finding myself doubting him, if he does improve like everyone else is assuming he will, he's not going to get me any extra wins in the leagues because most of my opponents will have him too, so for now I'm with Zaha.. he's not feeling much love from a lot of the DT players right now like he was at the start of the season. :-\