Polec vs Caddy vs Congilio

[Centurions]

THoughts?

[scotty_222]

conigilio..

[Capper]

Rookie, save your money or spend it on upgrading a rookie to prem

[SydneyRox]

Right at this moment I am on coniglio as well. One of the main reasons is at his price it will not effect my overall team if I decide over the next 4weeks he is not the best option.

[Centurions]

im really liking the look of polec this year as my 5th midfielder but not sure if he is going to outscore 106k rookies ( James Mcdonald, Clay Smith etc. ) to chose him

[Colliwobblers]

i have caddy in SC (sooooo cheap) but cant afford him in DT. He is a super star like a really big superstar, not sure about the suns but he is capable of pulling a barlow in his first full year, and the bombers believed it.

[Enter The Swan]

Caddy!

[specky lecky]

Caddy and Polec are both guns no doubt about it. If Caddy can avoid any injuries he is the best out of the lot. He's off to Arizona so we won't be seeing him in the NAB. The question surrounding Polec is whether he is in the best 22 at the bears. I think he is but can't see him playing 22 games this year. Conglilo will line up for round 1 and probably play every game if his body allows it.
I would go Cady as he is the best out of the lot. Congliio is a first year rookie. To me he isn't in the same group as Polec and Caddy, because he's a first year and he's cheaper. Make Caddy your fifth mid and put someone like shiel, trelor, kedridge or Kavanagh on your bench

[Centurions]

Caddy and Polec are both guns no doubt about it. If Caddy can avoid any injuries he is the best out of the lot. He's off to Arizona so we won't be seeing him in the NAB. The question surrounding Polec is whether he is in the best 22 at the bears. I think he is but can't see him playing 22 games this year. Conglilo will line up for round 1 and probably play every game if his body allows it.
I would go Cady as he is the best out of the lot. Congliio is a first year rookie. To me he isn't in the same group as Polec and Caddy, because he's a first year and he's cheaper. Make Caddy your fifth mid and put someone like shiel, trelor, kedridge or Kavanagh on your bench

thats what i was thinking and i had brought it down to either polec or caddy and im trying to factor the r.11-13 byes as well

[Colliwobblers]

JS worries me about polec, me i'll go caddy or cheapest rook that shines in nab cup. think caddy will come back from altitude training and swan it up.

[Bruce McAvaney]

coniglio

[Centurions]

Is Polecs JS worse than Caddy? I thought itd be the same

[Colliwobblers]

polec was dropped to the neafl last season for 7 games before he was injured, that wouldnt happen to caddy at gcs. lions arent exactly starved for quality midfielders.

[Ringo]

Caddy for me as I also doubt Polec's job security. He will be fighting the likes of Zorko, Bartlett (who I rate highly) Sheldon, Lester, Stiller, Harwood, Beams and Bewick for position in Lions 22.