my team for 2012 please rate out of 100 opinions welcomed...

Brocky101 · February 13, 2012, 04:01:17 PM

My first draft for the 2012 Dream team, all ideas very welcomed,

DEF: Goddard B, Birchall G, Enright C, Grimes J, Tomlinson A, Deledio B, Clarke M, (Morris S, Talia M)

MIDS: Swan D, Boyd M, Ablett G, Thompson S, Wingard C, Zorko D (Brown L, Mitchell T)

RUCKS: Goldstein T, Giles J, (Derickx T, Stephenson O,)

FORWARDS: Franklin L, Goods A, Silvia C, Riewoldt N, Porplyzia J,Hampton C, Walsh T, (Treloar A, Rowe S)

REM SAL CAP : $128 600

yorgis · February 13, 2012, 06:00:53 PM

3 gun def out in rnd 13. don't like the 3 rookie ruck set up, and sylvia was way too up and down for me last year. i would

downgrade 1 of the 3 def to ellis/mohr/smedts and sylvia to pav/fyfe/sidey, then upgrade your rucks to cox/sandi/luey

jacobs/mummy/mcevoy [take your pick-who you can afford

Brocky101 · February 13, 2012, 06:51:23 PM

DEF: Goddard B, Ellis B, Enright C, Grimes J, Tomlinson A, Deledio B, Clarke M, (Morris S, Talia M)

MIDS: Swan D, Boyd M, Ablett G, Thompson S, Wingard C, Zorko D (Brown L, Mitchell T)

RUCKS: Goldstein T, Cox D, (Derickx T, Stephenson O,)

FORWARDS: Franklin L, Goods A, Pav M, Riewoldt N, Porplyzia J,Hampton C, Walsh T, (Treloar A, Rowe S)

REM SAL CAP : $340,000

Cheers for your advice, just a bit lost on who is injured and who is actually in form this year... you advice be great appreciated

Paulie · February 14, 2012, 01:54:02 AM

Brocky101 team 4/10 ;D

TheHanger · February 14, 2012, 08:08:51 AM

Quote from: Paulie on February 14, 2012, 01:54:02 AM
Brocky101 team 4/10 ;D

mate if you give 4/10 you have to tell him why

Paulie · February 14, 2012, 02:37:07 PM

hanger ...relax we know each other ok

a bit of friendly banta thats all

BC2010 · February 14, 2012, 03:41:17 PM

My theory is that the best cheaps and rookies are to be found in the backs (Hargrave, Lake, B.Smith, Clarke, B.Ellis, Morris etc etc).

Concerned about the forward rooks/cheapies, so I am loading up in this area.

Given this, I would downgrade Grimes and/or Enright and upgrade Porps and/or Walsh.

Also, not sure of Tomlinson's JS - and Porps, Lids and Mitchell are all carrying various pre-season injuries.

Justin Bieber · February 16, 2012, 02:37:01 PM

KIt might be banter, but remembing your team Paulie you can't talk.