D Martin vs D Petrie

[oconnell]

please vote and give comment if u have anything to say :)

[tor01doc]

Martin is on the rise.

Petrie will struggle to match last year's output.

Martin > Petrie by about 200 points last year AND DPP.

Reckon poll will end up 9:1 in favour of the Dustbin.

Martin v Cloke is more interesting.

[Colliwobblers]

matin by a LONG way except before or after the bye round, REALLY tough first half draw for the tigers....

[oconnell]

matin by a LONG way except before or after the bye round, REALLY tough first half draw for the tigers....

its for my starting team

[pavs nose]

Martin is on the rise.

Petrie will struggle to match last year's output.

Martin > Petrie by about 200 points last year AND DPP.

Reckon poll will end up 9:1 in favour of the Dustbin.

Martin v Cloke is more interesting.

can you give a reason as to why petrie would struggle to match last years output. heres 2 reasons why he will be better;

* second year after missing pretty much an entire season so should be fitter.
* less likely to be double/triple teamed with either goldy or hmac floating around the forward line = more mark/kick/goals

but having said that i think martin will ave 10 ppg more

[Colliwobblers]

he will struggle (maybe) due to the return of HMac = no ruck time for Petrie and shared target up forward, every kick won't go to him this season.

[tor01doc]

I think North are on the slide. Not every team can improve - think Freo / Ess / Melb / Bulldogs / Adelaide / even Tigers will improve.

H Mc.

Agree he'll be fitter but opportunities will be fewer I think.

Dustbin for me.

[pavs nose]

he will struggle (maybe) due to the return of HMac = no ruck time for Petrie and shared target up forward, every kick won't go to him this season.

good points but i still think he'll get better due to my earlier points. rate the big fella very highly. consistency is his biggest issue though

[tor01doc]

Now big nosed guy, you're making me doubt myself!

Pity he's not DPP.

[pavs nose]

Now big nosed guy, you're making me doubt myself!

Pity he's not DPP.

Go with you gut mate. Can't go wrong with either of these 2