Sylvia Vs Martin

[dcp317]

What do people think about these 2? have either? both? i am not entirely convinced of martin given his up and down scores last year (same for sylvia too) and martin's hard draw first half...both at a tempting price given their upsides...

[Windigo]

We know Sylvia can score better than he did last year. But we dunno what he'll do really.  :P

D_Mart is a solid pick. But IMO not the 'lock' I originally thought he was. Tough draw too start with and I'll sit back and watch until after their bye...Then get him....Or not.  :o

[dcp317]

for some reason, i think sylvia will bang out some good consistent scores this year - neeld strikes me as a guy that will demand consistency from him and not put up with any petulant performances...the good thing is sylvia does it all - kicks, marks, tackles, goals...

[Windigo]

He sure does!

Also does get a few too many niggles.  :P

[elephants]

Sylvia in the middle = GUN
Sylvia in the fwd line = WTF

Risky but maybe with $cully leaving Sylvia can jump in. Had him last year so NO from me (unless he pumps out 110+ in the nab)

[Football Factory]

Could be wrong but i thought Sylvia was suspended for round 1 ....  Drinky Drinky Car Stacky ?

[Football Factory]

Yep he is

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/7415/newsid/125639/default.aspx

Colin must immediately complete an AFLPA and Club approved alcohol programme.- Colin will be fined $5,000, the maximum fine in accordance with the AFL/AFLPA Code of Conduct
- Suspended for Round 1 of 2012 AFL Premiership Season

[Torpedo10]

I'm not starting either but If I had to choose 1 I'd choose Martin. I'm looking at Martin as an upgrade target.

[elephants]

I'm not starting either but If I had to choose 1 I'd choose Martin. I'm looking at Martin as an upgrade target.

+1
Stupid, stupid boy Colin.