M Murphy, Porp and Lake vs Shaw, N Roo and Coniglio

[Nick_1069]

which combination of players would you choose for your side.

Option one you get a premium mid in Murphy as opposed to a rookie in Coniglio.
BUT, you then have to risk getting Lake and Porp ahead of Shaw and Nick Riewoldt in the back and fowards.

fairly stuck on this one so would appreciate some ideas.

thanks!

[Colliwobblers]

cant answer it without seeing the rest of your side if you have 3 premium mids take the murphy option if you already have 4 maybe go the rookie mid option.

Balance is key and i like a midfield of 4/4 gun rook

leave the mid pricers for the FWD and DEF

[Nick_1069]

current mids is ablett, swan and selwood with rookies so adding murphy would mean 4 premiums.

[yorgis]

you can always upgrade coniglio to murphy or another mid premo, but nroo should go up in value and shaw ,well who

knows!! either way is ok but i'd be tempted to go with the nroo option

[Colliwobblers]

murph then i'd hate to go in with less than 4 premiums or 3.5 anyway.

[Capper]

Coniglio, N Roo and Shaw

too many questions regarding Lake and Porps