J.J's Cannons update! Please Rate it and I will rate yours!

Started by Jake8, February 10, 2012, 09:51:28 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Jake8

Here it is. Please rate it because I need other opinions.
Backs:Goddard,Deledio,Broughton,H Shaw,Clarke,Lake,Mohr(B Ellis,S Morris)
Midfield:Ablett,Swan,Selwood,Barlow,K Stevens,D Shiel(McDonald,T Mitchell)
Rucks:Leuenberger,Natuinai(Giles,Stephenson)
Forwards:Franklin,Martin,J Brown,Pavlich,Proplyzia,Zorko,Smedts(Hampton,Pfeiffer)
Please rate my team! Please!!!!

Capper


DCAK

Backs:Goddard,Deledio,Broughton,H Shaw,Clarke,Lake,Mohr(B Ellis,S Morris)
Midfield:Ablett,Swan,Selwood,Barlow,K Stevens,D Shiel(McDonald,T Mitchell)
Rucks:Leuenberger,Natuinai(Giles,Stephenson)
Forwards:Franklin,Martin,J Brown,Pavlich,Proplyzia,Zorko,Smedts(Hampton,Pfeiffer)

Hi mate, here's my take on your team:
DEF: I think you can only pick Lake if he shows something in the NAB cup, unless you know something we don't. Also, like me you have 3 x Richmond defenders, which seems excessive, I'm trying to figure out which one of Ellis/Morris to dump, and who to replace them with.
MID: Like it, is Mitchell training in the rehab group at Syd? They are not a club that rush the rookies in either.
Ruck: Fine.
FWD: The porpoise eh.... time will tell

You have chosen to take 2 x deliberate risks (Lake/Porplyzia). So for me you seem to have too much risk, ie what evidence is there to suggest Lake will return to his best? We'd all love to grab a bargain but thats just wistful thinking. Porp is also very injury prone. With that in mind I'll give your team 8/10. Fairly standard team.

Jake8

Ok. I am willing to take the risk on Lake and Porps. And yeh Tom Mitchell is in the rehab group and don't know how to replace him with. I have about $7000 left.